Bloomberg

exchanges1-1433

Health Insurance Exchanges

By Alex Nussbaum | Updated Oct. 2, 2013

The fate of Obamacare is likely to hinge on the success or failure of online shopping centers where people can comparison-shop for coverage, dubbed Health Benefit Exchanges by the 2010 Affordable Care Act and Health Insurance Marketplaces by the Obama administration. Think of an Expedia for medical plans instead of airplane tickets. The idea is for insurance companies to compete to offer affordable plans, mainly to those who don’t get insurance at work. Seven million people are expected to sign up in the first year, according to congressional estimates.

The Situation

Congress expected each state to create and manage its own exchange, but only 14 (plus Washington, D.C.) agreed to do so. The rest, reflecting hostility to Obamacare or concerns about the complexity of the task, opted to let Washington do all or part of the job in time to open for business on Oct. 1.

The Background

If exchanges work as intended, premiums will fall and more people will obtain insurance. If not, costs could rise, especially for younger customers. A few states started organizing their exchanges early and are predicting success; California said in May that insurers agreed to offer cheaper rates than many had predicted. But the technical hurdles are huge, some states have delayed critical functions and there is much debate over the practical fallout.

The Argument

Republicans are still pushing for a delay of exchanges, if not outright defunding, saying the technology isn’t ready and raising the specter of identity theft. Democrats say the exchanges may experience some setbacks but will ultimately offer consumers more choice and the security of guaranteed coverage. Over the long term, the system will add competition to the insurance market and empower consumers, supporters argue. Affordability remains the sharpest point of contention: The administration says premiums are lower than expected, offering a good deal especially for lower-income or sick Americans. Critics say the rates come with hefty out-of-pocket costs and severely restricted doctor networks and argue the law is pushing up costs for everybody else.

The Reference Shelf

  • Read the Affordable Care Act here. The section on exchanges begins on page 55.
  • The U.S. government has a calendar of key dates  while the Kaiser Family Foundation is tracking state progress.
  • compilation of new health law regulations published by the Health and Human Services Department.
  • A book by the former Obama adviser David Blumenthal covers the contentious history of health reform in “The Heart of Power.”
  • PriceWaterhouseCoopers reports on how the insurance industry is affected by the exchanges.
  • Bloomberg Visual Data has a chart with a state-by-state rundown of premiums.
  • Bloomberg News “Prognosis for Obamacare” coverage index.

To contact the writer of this QuickTake:

Alex Nussbaum in New York at anussbaum1@bloomberg.net

 

To contact the editor of this QuickTake:

Jonathan Landman at jlandman4@bloomberg.net