Photographer: The Asahi Shimbun via Getty Images

Japan's Shinto Shrines in Crisis Despite Abe Pushing Religion

  • Obama, Cameron set to visit Japan’s most sacred spiritual site
  • Some 41% of Japan’s 80,000 cash-strapped shrines may vanish

In Japan, the Ise Grand Shrine is considered one of the holiest sites in the Shinto religion, a faith whose rituals have been woven into the nation’s culture for centuries. Located more than 300 kilometers (190 miles) southwest of Tokyo, the historic complex of wooden buildings set in a deep forest is dedicated to the sun goddess Amaterasu, from whom Japan’s emperors are said to be descended.

Ise Jingu, as it is known in Japanese, is also fraught with political meaning this week for Prime Minister Shinzo Abe, who hosts a Group of Seven summit on the nearby and secluded Kashiko Island. Despite constitutional restrictions, Abe would like to see the indigenous religion play a more prominent role in Japanese society.

Ise Shrine
Ise Shrine
Photographer: The Asahi Shimbun via Getty Images

Yet as the international spotlight falls on Shinto’s equivalent of the Vatican, which draws 7 million or more visitors annually, Japan’s lesser shrines face a protracted financial crisis in a country with a decelerating population and younger generations far less attached to traditional rituals.

Abe is expected to take his guests to the shrine, in the latest instance of his promotion of Shintoism. He has held New Year’s press conferences at Ise and, in 2013, was the first premier since 1929 to take part in a rebuilding ceremony held there every 20 years, according to John Breen, a history professor at the International Research Center for Japanese Studies.

"Abe is much more focused on Shinto than almost any other post war prime minister," said Breen, "He is a key member of Shinto Seiji Renmei, a political association that has as its aim the location of Shinto at the heart of government," he added.

QuickTake Japan's Military

Ise is less controversial than the Yasukuni Shrine in Tokyo, which honors Japan’s war dead, including World War II leaders convicted as Class A war criminals. Visits to Yasukuni by Japanese leaders, including Abe, have sparked anger in China and South Korea, which suffered under Japan’s aggression in the first half of the 20th century.

Backlash

Nevertheless, Abe’s 2013 participation in the Ise ceremony drew criticism from Christians in Japan, who said it violated a constitutional ban on the government favoring any particular religion. For some, Shinto is still associated with past nationalism, even though the U.S. and its allies removed its status as the national religion at the end of the war.

"There’s no doubt that Shinto was used by the government during the war," said Katsuji Iwahashi, public relations chief at the Association of Shinto Shrines in Tokyo. "But is there a religion that has not been used as a reason for fighting? Shrines in themselves are not aggressive."

Shinzo Abe visits Ise Shrine on October 2013.
Shinzo Abe visits Ise Shrine on October 2013.
Photographer: Asahi Shimbun via Getty Images

Ise Shrine employs about 600 people and, according to Diamond business magazine, spent about 55 billion yen ($500 million) on replacing all its buildings and artifacts in 2013 -- the 62nd time it had carried out this ritual. Its high priests and priestesses are relatives of the Imperial family, and past visitors have included Queen Elizabeth II.

On a visit two weeks ahead of the May 26-27 G-7 summit, dozens of police clad in rain gear were already patrolling the shrine’s grounds among a steady stream of visitors.

For those who run the other 80,000 or so shrines in Japan, life can be hard. The country has only 20,000 priests, meaning that many of them supervise more than one shrine. 

Shrinking Shrines

Small shrines rely on visitors’ offerings or fees for blessings for everything from marriages to new buildings and cars. Priests often combine their religious duties with a job as a teacher or government employee, according to Iwahashi. Older priests are also increasingly struggling to find successors.

About 41 percent of Japan’s shrines are in danger of disappearing along with the rural communities that support them, estimates Kenji Ishii, a professor of religious studies at Kokugakuin University, one of only two Shinto colleges in Japan.

While the same trend is hitting Buddhist temples in rural areas, shrines are even worse off, according to Hidenori Ukai, a Buddhist priest and author of "Vanishing Temples -- the Loss of Regional Areas and Religion." That’s because temples charge their parishioners for the maintenance of family graves, he said.

"We joke that we take people’s bones hostage," Ukai said. "Things are hard for temples in areas with shrinking populations, but it’s worse for shrines" which do not conduct burial rites or offer graveyards, he added.

The tiny Koami Shrine in Tokyo.
The tiny Koami Shrine in Tokyo.
Photographer: Isabel Reynolds/Bloomberg

Tadaki Hattori, the 51-year-old chief priest of the tiny, 200 square-meter (240 square yard) Koami Shrine in the busy Nihonbashi area of central Tokyo, said he often tells his fellow priests that making a success of a shrine comes down to sheer effort. He decided to take a shot at full-time priesthood five years ago, after inheriting the 550-year-old shrine from his father.

What was once a lonely spot hemmed in by a parking lot Hattori’s father used to supplement his income, is now bustling with visitors. The run-down buildings have been spruced up with a new bronze roof paid for by donations, and paper lanterns sponsored by businesses hang at the entrance. Far from worrying over a successor, Hattori said all four of his children are interested in qualifying as priests.

Providing a warm welcome and being willing to explain the shrine to visitors or listen to their problems is key to creating good word-of-mouth, Hattori said. An English-language web page has also helped bring in some of the record numbers of foreign tourists in Tokyo.

"If people put in a bit more effort, I think things could improve," Hattori said. "They give up too easily. They think they can’t make money, but you don’t know until you try. I think this is a trend in Japanese society as a whole -- everyone is a bit weedy these days."

Before it's here, it's on the Bloomberg Terminal. LEARN MORE