• Banks and retailers move to capture tap-and-pay transactions
  • Apple, Google will see new competition in evolving market

American consumers will have more choices in 2016 for how they make purchases with their smartphones as big banks and retailers vie for market share against tech giants Apple Inc. and Google.

Companies like JPMorgan Chase & Co. and Wal-Mart Stores Inc. are rolling out their own products just as mobile-payment apps are catching on. By 2019, eMarketer estimates that the total value of transactions made by tapping a phone on an in-store terminal will reach $210 billion, up from $8.7 billion in 2015. For banks and retailers, that presents an opportunity to take on Apple Pay and Google’s Android Pay -- and maybe save on transaction fees to boot.

“Every one of the top 11 issuers of credit and debit cards by the end of next year will have their own version of Pay,” said Richard Crone, chief executive officer of Crone Consulting LLC. “Same for retailers. The big losers are going to be the ones with nothing.”

At stake is a fight over money and consumer data: Retailers loathe paying fees to accept credit cards in their stores and have long sought better data on what their customers buy, and when. Banks similarly dislike paying fees for Apple Pay transactions. Thus, financial institutions and retailers have incentive to push out their own mobile-payment services.

Here are some of the mobile wallets that will compete for consumers’ attention in 2016:

Chase Pay

JPMorgan Chase plans to introduce its own mobile wallet in mid-2016. Mobile-banking apps are already used by more than half of U.S. smartphone owners with bank accounts, according to the latest Federal Reserve survey. Chase plans to pre-load cards for 94 million customer accounts “so the customer doesn’t have to do anything but accept the terms and conditions,” Gordon Smith, CEO of consumer and community banking at JPMorgan Chase, said in a keynote at the Money20/20 conference in October. Chase still wants its cards in all mobile wallets, and has decided to support Apple Pay, Samsung Pay and other competing services.

Walmart Pay

Wal-Mart will begin accepting payments through its mobile app in all U.S. stores in the first half of 2016. About 22 million Walmart shoppers already use the app, which compares prices and offers discounts on items and will now let customers store their credit- and debit-card information.

MCX

Merchant Customer Exchange -- a consortium founded in August 2012 by merchants including Wal-Mart and Target Corp. -- is testing its CurrentC app with about 200 merchants in Columbus, Ohio. The service is not yet available nationwide. “There will be more than one successful player in the mobile-payments space, and we fully expect to be one of them,” said Brian Mooney, chief executive officer of MCX.

Apple Pay

Apple Pay is the market leader in tap-and-pay transactions, even after experiencing growing pains in 2015. The service’s in-store payment feature, however, only works with the latest Apple iPhones.

Android Pay

Google revamped its mobile-wallet service after scooping up rival Softcard, a joint venture of three wireless carriers. The company said in a Dec. 15 blog post that “millions of people” had signed up for the new Android Pay, with the majority using their Android smartphones to tap and make purchases for the first time.

Samsung Pay

Samsung Pay debuted in South Korea in August and became available in the U.S. in September. By October, U.S. Samsung Pay users made an average of eight transactions each. Unlike Apple Pay or Android Pay, Samsung’s mobile-payment service works on older in-store terminals, ensuring wider usage. Samsung Pay is only available on newer Galaxy smartphones.

PayPal

PayPal users can make purchases with their smartphones in a variety of ways, including at Macy’s Inc. and Home Depot Inc. retail stores. In 2016 the company will introduce a feature that will let customers tap their phones to pay in stores, pitting it more squarely against Apple Pay and Android Pay. PayPal has 173 million active users and can work on both the iPhone and Android phones like the Galaxy.

The mobile-payment field is getting crowded despite slow consumer adoption. About 1 percent of U.S. households making at least $75,000 a year were expected to do their holiday shopping using a mobile wallet, according to Bankrate’s Money Pulse survey.

“The reality is nobody has nailed the in-store experience yet,” said Anuj Nayar, senior director of global initiatives at PayPal.

Before it's here, it's on the Bloomberg Terminal. LEARN MORE