British Cows Hit the Beach as Farmers Demand Higher Milk Prices

Updated on
French Farmers Demonstrate Against Milk Prices
Farmers throw milk on the ground as they demonstrate against the market price of their products in Lyon, on July 23. Photographer: Philippe Desmazes/AFP via Getty Images

Dairy farmers in Britain were so upset by unprofitable prices that they brought cows to the beach in protest.

In Belgium, they burned tires and blocked roads with tractors, while French producers set up check points along the German and Spanish borders to prevent trucks from delivering imported cheese.

Just months after the European Union lifted caps on milk production, there’s too much of it and some farmers are going broke. EU prices have tumbled to a five-year low, compounded by a global surplus and shrinking demand that’s disrupted exports. China is cutting back purchases and Russia, once the largest buyer of EU butter and cheese, halted imports last year in retaliation for sanctions over its conflict with Ukraine.

“We’re heading toward complete and utter disaster,” said David Handley, the chairman of Farmers for Action, which organized about 100 protests at U.K. supermarkets. “Prices are not covering the cost of production.”

Dairy producers are demanding retailers pay more for milk and asking consumers to buy local products instead of cheaper imports. Farmers for Action set up “trolley dashes” in which protesters load a store’s entire milk supply into shopping carts and leave it at the cash register or buy it for charities.

Money Losers

Handley, a 63-year-old farmer in Raglan, Wales, said he will sell his 140-cow herd in the next few months because the business is no longer profitable. U.K. farmers get as little as 15 pence (23 cents) a liter for milk, well below the 25 pence each liter costs to produce, he said.

An EU gauge tracking consumer prices for milk, cheese and eggs has dropped 2.1 percent from last year. Retail prices for whole milk in France fell 5.6 percent since last year, according to the latest government data from June.

With prices so low, there’s little incentive for European producers to increase supply, even after EU regulators in April ended a system that had capped production for 30 years. This year, the EU expects output to rise 1 percent to 161.4 million tons.

The removal of quotas marked a change to an open-market system. Before the limits, government purchases of surpluses were intended to aid farmers but instead led to overproduction.

Farming Unions

While farming unions in countries including the U.K. and Germany favored the end of quotas, some still protested in Brussels last March. The European Milk Board said more rules are needed to limit price declines when there’s a glut.

The rest of the world is awash in supply. The price of whole-milk powder, which is exported more than fluid milk, plunged to the lowest in at least seven years at an international auction this week. Global production of fluid milk, cheese and butter will rise to records this year, the U.S. Department of Agriculture estimates.

In northeast England, people walked cows along Redcar Beach south of Durham last week to talk to shoppers about milk prices. Lithuanians dumped 30 metric tons of milk in early July in response to processors offering a “ridiculous” 10 cents a liter, the country’s milk producers’ association said. Tractors dumped manure outside a butter factory in Goe, Belgium, according to a report from the Associated Press.

Frustration, Fear

“These protests are born out of frustration and fear about what the next few months could bring,” said Ian Marshall, president of the Ulster Farmers Union in Belfast, Northern Ireland. The group didn’t participate in demonstrations that took place last week in front of the country’s parliament. “Farmers are running out of cash.”

In the U.K., protesters targeted retailers including Wm Morrison Supermarkets Plc and Wal-Mart Store Inc.’s Asda, Handley said. In June, Morrison cut prices for staple products including semi-skimmed milk and butter. The company said in a statement that it’s not seeking further reductions in milk prices from suppliers.

Prices paid to farmers by Royal FrieslandCampina NV and Arla Foods amba, the EU’s top dairy cooperatives, are more than 25 percent less than the same time last year, according to data on the companies’ websites.

Demand Falling

“We certainly understand the frustration of dairy farmers, but we feel that targeting retailers is misplaced,” said Andrew Opie, the director of food and sustainability at the British Retail Consortium, a London-based organization that represents supermarkets and other stores. “What we’ve seen is an oversupply of dairy products because of good production around the world and a falling off in demand.”

The plunge in dairy costs helped push down a gauge of global food prices in July to the lowest since September 2009, the United Nations’ Food & Agriculture Organization said Thursday.

Prices may not rebound until early next year because demand is still sluggish, said Kevin Bellamy, a senior dairy analyst at Rabobank International. Chinese imports of whole-milk powder will be the smallest in four years, USDA data show. Russia’s ban on EU food will remain for at least another year.

“It’s tough times for farmers,” Bellamy said by telephone from Utrecht, Netherlands. “There’s really too much milk on the world market.”

Before it's here, it's on the Bloomberg Terminal. LEARN MORE