Venezuelans in Panama Say They Can’t Go Home Again

Photographer: Juan Carlos Hernandez/Bloomberg

People hold a sign asking where basic goods are outside a grocery store in Barcelona, Venezuela. Venezuelans in Panama predict that a new wave of young, middle-class job seekers will follow them in the wake of shortages of basic goods, accelerating inflation and anti-government demonstrations that have claimed at least 41 lives since February. Close

People hold a sign asking where basic goods are outside a grocery store in Barcelona,... Read More

Close
Open
Photographer: Juan Carlos Hernandez/Bloomberg

People hold a sign asking where basic goods are outside a grocery store in Barcelona, Venezuela. Venezuelans in Panama predict that a new wave of young, middle-class job seekers will follow them in the wake of shortages of basic goods, accelerating inflation and anti-government demonstrations that have claimed at least 41 lives since February.

Leonardo Zambranok, who moved from Venezuela almost three years ago to take a marketing job with Procter & Gamble Co. in Panama, has watched the wave of violent protests back home and says he knows he made the right choice.

“Everyone said I was making a big mistake because they were still making a lot of money,” said Zambranok, 27, who like other Venezuelans fleeing economic and political instability thought the move would be temporary. “Now it’s more insecure than ever and you’re starting to see young people want to move away like crazy.”

An exodus that began under the late President Hugo Chavez has gotten a boost under Nicolas Maduro, who vowed to extend his predecessor’s socialist policies after winning elections last April. Venezuelans in Panama predict that a new wave of young, middle-class job seekers will follow them in the wake of shortages of basic goods, accelerating inflation and anti-government demonstrations that have claimed at least 41 lives since February.

With close cultural ties, more open immigration laws and plentiful jobs, Panama offers some advantages over traditional destinations like south Florida, Venezuelans say.

Panama’s immigration agency said 233,921 Venezuelans entered the country to work or visit last year, up from about 147,000 in 2010. That compares with approximately 223,000 non-immigrant and immigrant visas issued to Venezuelans by the U.S. last year, according to the State Department. Venezuelans seeking work in Panama often come on a tourist visa and change their status later.

Photographer: Susana Gonzalez/Bloomberg

Panama’s immigration agency said 233,921 Venezuelans entered the country to work or visit last year, up from about 147,000 in 2010. Close

Panama’s immigration agency said 233,921 Venezuelans entered the country to work or... Read More

Close
Open
Photographer: Susana Gonzalez/Bloomberg

Panama’s immigration agency said 233,921 Venezuelans entered the country to work or visit last year, up from about 147,000 in 2010.

Familiar Trappings

For Venezuelans, Panama also offers many of the trappings of home. There are dozens of Venezuelan-run restaurants, yoga studios and bakeries in Panama City. Cable television packages include Globovision, a Venezuelan channel that has sparred with the socialist government since Chavez.

Cars sporting signs with “SOS Venezuela,” a slogan of anti-Maduro protesters, are regularly seen around Panama City. At pick-up soccer games in the capital, Zambranok said conversations bounce from hardships at home to opportunities in the new locale, with more acquaintances reaching out for work.

“Our culture is about relationships, where you know a guy who knows a guy who can help you,” said Zambranok. He shows a photo of a friend standing in front of mayonnaise jars at a Caracas supermarket, taken amid recent shortages. “This is big news when you can get mayonnaise. It’s absurd.”

Venezuela’s Information Ministry didn’t respond to a message left by Bloomberg News regarding emigration to Panama and other countries.

Highest Inflation

Under Maduro, Venezuelan inflation has surged to 57 percent, the highest in the world. More than one in four basic goods was out of stock in Latin America’s fourth-largest economy in January, according to the central bank, which has stopped publishing up-to-date scarcity data. The government last month let the bolivar weaken 88 percent in a new currency market, part of a move to increase dollar supplies in South America’s biggest oil exporter.

Wedged between Colombia and Costa Rica, Panama has lured workers with economic growth that has averaged about 9 percent per year since 2008 as completion nears on a $5.25 billion expansion of its signature canal. That’s prompted investments in banks, mining and real estate, including a new Hard Rock hotel, and created more jobs.

“We’ve had to open up our immigration policy to attract more skilled labor,” Panama Finance Minister Frank De Lima said in an April 9 interview.

Venezuelan Investment

As unemployment levels hover near a record low of 4.1 percent, Panama’s immigration agency said this month that it has legalized about 50,000 foreign workers since 2010 in a series of open registrations, called “melting pots.” Of the 5,072 foreign workers approved in the April melting pot, 603 were Venezuelan, the fourth-highest number after immigrants from Colombia, the Dominican Republic and Nicaragua.

The government also eased requirements to gain residency for immigrants from more than 40 nations deemed friendly to the Central American country. Citizens from the U.S. and elsewhere can work in Panama or start a business by opening a $5,000 local bank account.

Venezuela is not on that list. Even so, Panama has “seen an increase of Venezuelan investment, companies and entrepreneurs in the last couple of years,” De Lima said.

Santiago Medina, a 27-year-old Venezuelan stock broker living in Panama, said any aspirations to return home have been dashed by Maduro.

‘More Comfortable’

“I’d love to go back, but there are too many unknowns right now,” said Medina, who moved to Panama in 2008 and works at Banco General SA. “I’m way more comfortable here.”

Panama experienced a surge of Venezuelan brokerage license applications after Chavez’s 2010 crackdown on financial firms, which sent 11 traders to jail. Eight of 12 firms applying for licenses at the time were from Venezuela, according to Panama’s security regulator.

While Medina and Zambranok had visas sponsored by their employers, other Venezuelans said they found jobs initially while under their six-month tourist status and then applied to work legally.

Zambranok, who jumped at a transfer offer when his company expanded their offices in Panama City, said the transition has been far easier than it would have been in south Florida.

“Panama is still Latin America, it’s a lot more relaxed here,” he said.

There is also a high demand for workers. In Panama’s $36 billion economy, 38 percent of employers reported difficulty filling vacancies last year, with the biggest shortages in technical support and sales representatives, according to a ManpowerGroup survey.

Lead Growth

Fueled by the 100-year-old canal’s expansion, Panama may lead Latin America in economic growth, expanding 7 percent compared with a 1 percent contraction in Venezuela, the World Bank forecast in an April 9 report. Economic activity expanded 4.3 percent in February from a year earlier.

The country of 3.6 million people has among the highest job turnover rates in the region and companies are willing to bend the rules to retain foreign workers, said Alberto Alesi, the Panama director for ManpowerGroup.

“You can’t hire a civil engineer from Venezuela because it’s a protected job for Panamanians,” Alesi said in an interview. “So some firms hire an engineer from Venezuela, but as a technician. It’s the same job, just less pay.”

The migration comes amid heightening tensions with Venezuela’s government. In March, Maduro severed diplomatic and commercial relations with Panama, accusing President Ricardo Martinelli of stoking foreign intervention he said was behind this year’s protests.

Open Borders

Martinelli has vowed to keep the borders open to Venezuelans as he demands Latin American’s biggest oil exporter pay $1 billion of debt owed to Panama companies.

“We want Venezuela to respect human rights,” Martinelli said in a March 13 interview in Panama City. “It’s very sad to see all the violence, the people being killed.”

Panamanians head to the polls on May 4 to elect a new president, with crime and inflation dominating voter concerns as candidates pledge further public investment to maintain economic growth. The nation’s constitution forbids Martinelli from running a second, consecutive term.

Ivana Rabbat said she initially felt out of place when her mother moved the family from Caracas to Panama City four years ago, fearing for their safety. Now 24, Rabbat helps manage a hotel in the city’s historic Casco Viejo district and is taking night classes to study project management.

Her mother returned to work as an attorney in Venezuela. During a recent visit to Panama, Rabbat said she has been trying to convince her to stay.

“The first couple of years were really tough,” she said. “But now I can say this is my country.”

To contact the reporter on this story: Eric Sabo in Panama City at esabo1@bloomberg.net

To contact the editors responsible for this story: Bill Faries at wfaries@bloomberg.net; Andre Soliani at asoliani@bloomberg.net Gail DeGeorge

Press spacebar to pause and continue. Press esc to stop.

Bloomberg reserves the right to remove comments but is under no obligation to do so, or to explain individual moderation decisions.

Please enable JavaScript to view the comments powered by Disqus.