TransCanada Asks Texas Supreme Court to Skip Keystone Review

TransCanada Corp. (TRP) asked the Texas Supreme Court to reject a farmer’s request to review condemnation rulings allowing the Keystone XL pipeline to cross her land against her will.

Julia Trigg Crawford has asked the state high court to review two lower-court decisions giving TransCanada the right to use eminent-domain statutes to install its 2,151-mile Canadian tar-sands pipeline across property her family has farmed for generations in northeastern Texas.

Crawford claims that TransCanada, a foreign company transporting oil produced out of state, doesn’t qualify as a common-carrier under state law and isn’t entitled to condemn her land for private use. The lower courts agreed with the company that it did qualify.

“Crawford’s issues fly in the face of the Legislature’s active encouragement of a common carrier pipeline system throughout Texas, not only to transport Texas production, but also to bring critical feedstock into Texas to fuel Texas refineries,” Tom Zabel, TransCanada’s lawyer, said in a filing urging the court to reject her challenge.

Legal Theories

Crawford is one of a handful of Texas farmers fighting TransCanada’s use of eminent domain under various legal theories, which has sparked a statewide debate over property rights. None of the challengers has prevailed so far, and Crawford’s case is the second to reach the Texas Supreme Court.

TransCanada initially said in court filings that it didn’t think a formal answer to Crawford’s request for review was required. The company’s filing at the high court in Austin yesterday came after the justices expressed interest in hearing the landowner’s case.

The company urged the high court to refuse Crawford’s request, just as the justices declined last year to review a similar Keystone challenge from Rhinoceros Ventures. That group owns property near Beaumont, at the pipeline’s southern terminus.

The case is The Crawford Family Farm Partnership v. TransCanada Keystone Pipeline, 13-0886, Supreme Court of Texas.

To contact the reporter on this story: Laurel Brubaker Calkins in Houston at

To contact the editor responsible for this story: Michael Hytha at

Press spacebar to pause and continue. Press esc to stop.

Bloomberg reserves the right to remove comments but is under no obligation to do so, or to explain individual moderation decisions.

Please enable JavaScript to view the comments powered by Disqus.