Bobby Cannavale Fights Success in ‘The Big Knife’: Review

Photographer: Joan Marcus/Polk & Co. P.R. via Bloomberg

Richard Kind, Bobby Cannavale and Chip Zien in Clifford Odets's Hollywood morality tale "The Big Knife," on Broadway. The drama is directed by Doug Hughes. Close

Richard Kind, Bobby Cannavale and Chip Zien in Clifford Odets's Hollywood morality tale... Read More

Close
Open
Photographer: Joan Marcus/Polk & Co. P.R. via Bloomberg

Richard Kind, Bobby Cannavale and Chip Zien in Clifford Odets's Hollywood morality tale "The Big Knife," on Broadway. The drama is directed by Doug Hughes.

Bobby Cannavale has been a dominant presence on Broadway for several seasons. After a middling revival of “Glengarry Glen Ross” last November, he’s back and looking sleekly feral in Clifford Odets’s “The Big Knife.”

This is the second revival this season of a play by Odets who died 50 years ago. Like “Golden Boy,” it’s a fable in which the price of success American-style is your soul.

Cannavale’s Charlie Castle first shows up in tennis whites, the embodiment of the leisure class, having traded the uncertainty and impoverishment of a New York stage actor for swashbuckling stardom in Hollywood.

The goodies include a beautiful wife Marion (Marin Ireland), a posh house (impeccably designed by John Lee Beatty with cathedral ceilings, natural wood, modern art and light reflecting off the pool) and a flock of fawning toadies to do his bidding.

Charlie’s done an admirable job of convincing himself he’s happy, but Marion seems to know better.

At the play’s opening, she has removed herself to their beach house in the hope that Charlie will have the guts not to renew his studio contract. She wants him to get back to the serious stuff.

Best Interests

His unctuous agent, Nat (Chip Zien, painfully perfect), is of course desperate for him to re-up, while professing to have only Charlie’s best interests at heart.

Photographer: Joan Marcus/Polk & Co. P.R. via Blomberg

Marin Ireland and Bobby Cannavale in the Broadway revival of "The Big Knife." The Clifford Odets play is being produced by the Roundabout Theatre Company. Close

Marin Ireland and Bobby Cannavale in the Broadway revival of "The Big Knife." The... Read More

Close
Open
Photographer: Joan Marcus/Polk & Co. P.R. via Blomberg

Marin Ireland and Bobby Cannavale in the Broadway revival of "The Big Knife." The Clifford Odets play is being produced by the Roundabout Theatre Company.

Art or mammon -- which will carry the day?

This is Odets, so the answer is going to be complicated, drawn out and melodramatic.

Cursed with the moral fire of Arthur Miller but not Miller’s poetry, Odets’s morality tales are pretty lumpish and heavy-handed.

Keen ears will hear in the 1949 “Big Knife” the voices and themes that will find sharper and even more acrid form in “Sweet Smell of Success,” his ferocious indictment of Hollywood that would set the bar for an industry’s self- contempt.

Director Doug Hughes and his fine cast haven’t been able to unstack the cards Odets sets against Charlie.

They include Charlie’s involvement in a violent death for which one of the toadies took the rap; the threat of retribution from Richard Kind’s brutal, vulgar studio chief; infidelity and abortion. Not even Marion is immune to the corrosive seductions of the good life.

None of this realism seems, well, real.

Swanky Clothes

We can, however, enjoy the pile-up of unpleasant plot turns as they play out on that luscious set, shimmeringly lit by James F. Ingalls. Best of all are Catherine Zuber’s swank clothes: double-breasted blazers and gabardine slacks for the goons; drapey, clingy dresses for the women.

Photographer: Joan Marcus/Polk & Co. P.R. via Bloomberg

Richard Kind is a ruthless movie producer and Bobby Cannavale his biggest action star in "The Big Knife." The revival has costumes by Catherine Zuber. Close

Richard Kind is a ruthless movie producer and Bobby Cannavale his biggest action star... Read More

Close
Open
Photographer: Joan Marcus/Polk & Co. P.R. via Bloomberg

Richard Kind is a ruthless movie producer and Bobby Cannavale his biggest action star in "The Big Knife." The revival has costumes by Catherine Zuber.

Like many a Hollywood creation, “The Big Knife” has a come-hither look it can’t quite make good on.

Through June 2 at the American Airlines Theatre, 227 W. 42nd St. Information: +1-719-1300; http://www.roundabouttheatre.org. Rating: ***

(Jeremy Gerard is the chief U.S. drama critic for Muse, the arts and leisure section of Bloomberg News. The opinions expressed are his own.)

Muse highlights include Ryan Sutton on restaurants and Craig Seligman on movies.

To contact the writer of this column: Jeremy Gerard in New York at jgerard2@bloomberg.net.

To contact the editor responsible for this story: Manuela Hoelterhoff at mhoelterhoff@bloomberg.net.

Bloomberg reserves the right to remove comments but is under no obligation to do so, or to explain individual moderation decisions.

Please enable JavaScript to view the comments powered by Disqus.