Black Smoke Over St. Peter’s Signals No Pope Elected

March 11 (Bloomberg) -- Julie Hyman reports today's top news headlines from around the world on Bloomberg Television's "Rewind." (Source: Bloomberg)

Roman Catholic cardinals failed to elect a successor to retired Pope Benedict XVI as black smoke rose over St. Peter’s Basilica signaling an inconclusive vote.

Cardinals under the voting-age limit of 80, who total 115, began their conclave in Rome today, singing a prayer to saints to guide their decision as they entered the Sistine Chapel and kneeled under Michelangelo’s fresco of the Last Judgment. They took a vow to keep secret any details of the proceedings, with violations bringing excommunication including for support staff.

“We clerics and lay people promise and pledge to maintain, with the utmost faithfulness, secrecy over everything that concerns the election of the Roman Pontiff, and everything that takes place in the election,” Italian Cardinal Giovanni Batista Re said in Latin before the cardinals took their vows.

Hailing from six continents, the red-hatted “princes of the church” will choose a new leader of the world’s 1.2 billion Catholics amid a waning church presence in Europe and North America and expansion in Asia and Africa. One ballot is held on the first day, after which as many as four votes a day can be conducted. The elections of John Paul II in 1978 and his successor Benedict in 2005 took three days and two days, respectively. One 13th-century conclave dragged on for three years.

Photographer: Franco Origlia/Getty Images

Brazilian Cardinal Odilo Schrerer attends the Pro Eligendo Romano Pontifice Mass at St Peter's Basilica, before they enter the conclave to decide who the next pope will be, on March 12, 2013 in Vatican City, Vatican. Close

Brazilian Cardinal Odilo Schrerer attends the Pro Eligendo Romano Pontifice Mass at St... Read More

Close
Open
Photographer: Franco Origlia/Getty Images

Brazilian Cardinal Odilo Schrerer attends the Pro Eligendo Romano Pontifice Mass at St Peter's Basilica, before they enter the conclave to decide who the next pope will be, on March 12, 2013 in Vatican City, Vatican.

Tens of thousands people gathered under rainy skies in St. Peter’s to stare at the tube-shaped chimney erected over the Sistine chapel that signals the results of the vote.

Betting Odds

Italian Cardinal Angelo Scola is currently the favorite to become pope with 9-to-4 odds to take over after Benedict’s Feb. 28 abdication, according to betting company William Hill Plc. Cardinal Peter Turkson of Ghana is second at 7-to-2 with Italian Cardinal Tarcisio Bertone following on odds of 5-to-1.

The German-born Benedict, 85, who on Feb. 11 said he no longer had the strength to lead the church, was the first pope to resign since Gregory XII in 1415. The process of electing his successor will offer few signs about the winner until white smoke wafts over St. Peter’s Square.

“We won’t be sending any text messages” to announce the new pope’s election, Vatican spokesman Federico Lombardi said at a press briefing on March 9. “A little bit of suspense is one of the nice things about this event.”

During the conclave cardinals must remain in the 15th- century Sistine Chapel, adorned with Michelangelo’s frescoes, or their lodgings in the Vatican. They are barred from any communications with the outside world and have no access to telephones, computers or television.

Photographer: Johannes Eisele/AFP/Getty Images

Italian Cardinal Angelo Scola is currently the favorite to become pope with 9-to-4 odds to take over after Benedict’s Feb. 28 abdication, according to betting company William Hill Plc. Close

Italian Cardinal Angelo Scola is currently the favorite to become pope with 9-to-4 odds... Read More

Close
Open
Photographer: Johannes Eisele/AFP/Getty Images

Italian Cardinal Angelo Scola is currently the favorite to become pope with 9-to-4 odds to take over after Benedict’s Feb. 28 abdication, according to betting company William Hill Plc.

White, Black

When no candidate wins the required two-thirds of the votes, ballots are burned with a chemical to emit black smoke over St. Peter’s Square. White smoke signals a new pope, who’s later accompanied to a balcony over St. Peter’s Square with the proclamation “Habemus Papam,” Latin for “We have a pope.”

Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, who became Pope Benedict XVI, was elected after two days and four ballots on April 19, 2005, 17 days after John Paul’s death.

“Every time there is an election of a new pope, it’s a new era,” Canadian Cardinal Marc Ouellet, 68, said on March 4 on Radio-Canada TV. While unexpected, the possibility of becoming pontiff “makes me pray, it scares me a little bit.”

Of the 115 cardinal electors, sixty-seven were created by Benedict and 48 by John Paul II. They spent the last week with cardinals above the voting age discussing challenges facing the church and sizing up papal candidates, including possibly electing the first non-European pope in more than a millennium.

Papal Leaks

Some of the debates focused on how to improve the work of the Vatican bureaucracy known as the Curia in light of the so- called “Vatileaks” case involving leaked papal documents, which depicted a web of Vatican intrigue undermining Benedict’s governance of the global church.

The place of women in the church was also on the agenda, according to the Vatican, with discussion of the need to get rid of barriers to their leadership of Catholic institutions.

The cardinals also pondered how to reconnect with a Western culture that now largely rejects Catholic teachings on contraception and homosexuality, fails to understand why women can’t be priests and lacks interest in topics of a more theological nature.

“The church is bleeding in the West,” said Jack Valero, a founder of U.K.-based Catholic Voices, an international group that trains lay people to speak publicly about church issues.

“If the doctrine is right, then we need new ways to explain it because it has become incomprehensible to vast numbers of people,” Valero said in a telephone interview from London yesterday. “That is a huge job.”

To contact the reporter on this story: Bryan Bradley in Vilnius at bbradley13@bloomberg.net

To contact the editor responsible for this story: Balazs Penz at bpenz@bloomberg.net

Bloomberg reserves the right to edit or remove comments but is under no obligation to do so, or to explain individual moderation decisions.

Please enable JavaScript to view the comments powered by Disqus.