The underperformance of European stocks relative to their U.S. counterparts may be ending, even as investors await the details of a plan for the European Central Bank to join forces with governments to ease the euro area’s debt crisis.
The Euro Stoxx 50 Index -- a benchmark of blue-chip shares -- has risen 5.9 percent since July 25, the day before ECB President Mario Draghi pledged that policy makers were “ready to do whatever it takes to preserve the euro.” The Standard & Poor’s 500 Index has risen 2.2 percent in the same period. The recent outperformance comes after the European index lagged behind the S&P 500 by almost 80 percent between March 9, 2009, when the U.S. index hit a 13-year low, and June 18, 2012.
The ECB’s governing council, which met today in Frankfurt, kept its benchmark interest rate at a record low of 0.75 percent. Dragi, speaking after the meeting, signaled that the central bank intends to work with governments to buy sovereign bonds in sufficient quantities to remove all doubts about the future of the euro, with details to be determined in coming weeks.
The Euro Stoxx 50 fell 1.5 percent to 2,299.69, while the S&P 500 was down 0.2 percent to 1,372.77 as of 11:05 a.m. in New York, after Draghi failed to reassure investors seeking specific steps the ECB will take to bolster the economy.
Pioneer Investment Management Inc., which oversees about $185 billion in assets, “cautiously moved to a risk-on” position in European equities about a month ago while remaining underweight U.S. stocks as “most of the bad news” already may be built into market prices, said Monica Defend, head of global asset-allocation research in Milan. While this “appears to be a bold move” in the current market, “we should not underestimate the commitment of leading central banks” to provide support to the financial system, she said in an interview before the ECB meeting.
The rationale for this strategy is twofold: attractive valuations for European stocks and “most importantly, we were strongly convinced that the ECB would intervene” to solve the region’s debt crisis, Defend said. The ECB flooded markets with more than 1 trillion euros ($1.21 trillion) of cheap three-year loans in December and February.
“Risk premia that are related to fears of the reversibility of the euro are unacceptable, and they need to be addressed in a fundamental manner,” Draghi said at a press conference in Frankfurt. “The euro is irreversible.”
After Draghi’s July 26 speech, London-based UBS AG strategists Stephane Deo and Ramin Nakisa upgraded their recommended allocation of Europe’s equities from “underweight” to “neutral,” based on the prospect of a “structural shift” in monetary policy, they wrote in a July 29 report.
European underperformance started to end by mid-June, showing that investor sentiment was improving even before Draghi’s comments last week, said Jim Stellakis, founder and director of research at New York-based research company Technical Alpha Inc.
That’s in part because European stocks are at “a cheap and unloved starting point,” said Graham Secker, head of European equity strategy in London at Morgan Stanley. The Euro Stoxx 50 is trading at about 10.6 times its price-to-earnings ratio, compared with 13 times for the S&P 500, according to data provided by Defend. The historical average multiple is 15 for European stocks and 15.6 for U.S. stocks, she said.
Since Europe’s market stopped lagging behind the U.S. in June, followed by the strong price reaction to Draghi’s July 26 speech, now “betting against Europe is not attractive in the short-term,” Stellakis said. If the Euro Stoxx 50 can outpace the S&P 500 by about another 2 percent to 3 percent from current levels, a nearly two-year trend of investors underweighting European equities would be broken, he said.
A clear pattern of European outperformance could take months to develop amid a lot of market volatility, “but looking back, this could prove to be an important shift in investor sentiment,” Stellakis said.
Given how much the stocks have underperformed since 2009, even a “modest” change in prospects for “more aggressive” ECB policy action can cause European shares to rally more than U.S. counterparts, Secker said. “I certainly wouldn’t want to be underweight Europe versus the U.S. right now.”
Even so, underlying risks in the euro area may support such a recommendation on equities in Spain, Italy, Greece and Portugal, said Tom Elliott, a global strategist at JPMorgan Asset Management in London.
While he’s neutral on “core Europe,” including Germany and the Netherlands, the region’s equities will remain volatile until there’s “wholehearted conviction” from Germany and France to support politically an increase in fiscal support by the ECB, he said.
There’s now a “risk of disappointment” if there’s no substantive follow-through by the central bank, Elliott said. What’s more, the ECB is perceived to be reacting to the region’s fiscal crisis, rather than taking a proactive approach, which engenders little confidence among investors, he said.
The S&P 500 fell 0.3 percent to 1,375.32 yesterday, reversing earlier gains, after Federal Reserve Chairman Ben S. Bernanke held off on stepping up record stimulus at the central bank’s policy meeting, disappointing investors anticipating a more definitive sign of further monetary easing.
Though the “jury’s still out” on the ECB’s ability to achieve a swift resolution, Draghi’s pledge may mark a move in the right direction, said Morgan Stanley’s Secker.
“There’s more two-way risk for European equities now than there’s been in some time,” Secker said. “Europe is not just a one-way bet down.”
To contact the editor responsible for this story: Anthony Feld at firstname.lastname@example.org