Finra Retooling Market Surveillance to Catch Abuses
The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority is revamping how it scans for abuses such as insider trading, responding to increased fragmentation of markets, Chief Executive Officer Richard Ketchum said today.
Finra conducts market surveillance for most stock exchanges, reflecting 80 percent of U.S. trading, after adding NYSE Euronext’s markets to its oversight responsibilities in June. While the regulator currently operates separate databases for trading-related information for securities listed on the New York Stock Exchange and Nasdaq Stock Market, the goal is to “pull that together” in 2011 to spot manipulative and illegal activity across venues, Ketchum told reporters in New York.
With stock activity dispersed across as many as 50 venues including exchanges, electronic communication networks, dark pools and the trading desks of broker-dealers, manipulative practices have spread out in an attempt to elude regulators, he said. Dark pools are private venues that match orders without displaying quotes. Surveillance must aggregate data across markets to identify patterns and related trading, Ketchum said.
“Putting all that information together so people can see relationships” across markets is critical, he said. “That will come as our major task in 2011.”
Data for Nasdaq-listed securities and over-the-counter or off-exchange trading resides in one database, while NYSE and NYSE Arca information is in another, said Finra Vice Chairman Stephen Luparello. Adding the latter data into the former system will give regulators a “much fuller picture” of markets, he said. NYSE Euronext and Nasdaq OMX Group Inc. are based in New York. Finra, whose main task is overseeing more than 4,600 brokers, is based in Washington.
Finra conducts market surveillance, investigations, enforcement activities and regulation of member firms for NYSE, Nasdaq and other exchanges. It does “less than the complete sweep” for Bats Global Markets and Direct Edge Holdings LLC, with those exchange owners managing some of that business, Luparello said.
“We think that’s less than optimal,” he said. Finra would like to consolidate the data so its surveillance can operate across all 13 U.S. exchanges.
Finra received approval from the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission last month to expand the information it collects for orders and transactions in Nasdaq-listed securities to those listed on other exchanges including NYSE. The broader Order Audit Trail System will provide uniform data for all securities, enabling Finra to compile aggregated information that may be similar to the so-called consolidated audit trail the SEC proposed in May.
A consolidated audit trail system that comprises all trading-related data for orders would allow regulators to reconstruct market events such as the May 6 plunge that erased $862 billion in equity value in 20 minutes and strengthen surveillance, the SEC said when it presented its plan.
Expanding OATS would improve the data available to regulators in the coming months, Ketchum said. A separate proposal by the SEC to track the buying and selling by individuals and firms executing more than 2 million shares a day would help regulators understand what active traders are doing, he said. That system would also apply to traders processing $20 million in equities a day or $200 million in a month.
Looking for Patterns
Finra identifies many of the insider trading cases it investigates based on alerts from an electronic surveillance system it uses called Sonar, according to Cameron Funkhouser, executive vice president and head of Finra’s office of fraud detection and market intelligence. The system tracks news in publicly listed companies and identifies potential instances of abusive trading. Older investigations may also be roped into an analysis as the regulator looks for patterns across time.
Finra currently has between 200 to 400 active insider trading investigations, Funkhouser said. It’s referred up to six “serial insider-trading rings” to the SEC or other law enforcement agencies in the past two years, including one that led to the SEC’s Dec. 7 action against an information technology manager at a Delaware law firm and his brother-in-law, he said.
Finra in 2011 will also focus on manipulative activity that relies on algorithms or speed-focused automated trading strategies that submit buy and sell orders to marketplaces based on price data, Ketchum said.
“Most high-frequency trading activity is legitimate,” Ketchum said. “It doesn’t involve manipulative activity and operates entirely within the law.” Still, “we do see instances where it’s not,” he said. His organization sees activity that ranges “from things that might be troubling to things that are fraud,” he said.
An example of the type of activity Finra will pursue more aggressively is the case it announced in September against Trillium Brokerage Services LLC, a proprietary trading firm that engaged in activity aimed at inducing other firms to respond to its bids and offers, Ketchum said. Trillium employed manipulative practices that high-frequency traders’ computers were likely to identify as market-moving activity, prompting them to react to the firm’s quotes, he said. Finra’s sanctions against the firm and 11 employees totaled $2.3 million, according to a notice.
That’s a “good example of what you’re going to see going into 2011 with respect to market surveillance,” Ketchum said. “We redesigned our surveillance to be much more focused on this type of activity.”
To contact the editor responsible for this story: Nick Baker at firstname.lastname@example.org.
Bloomberg moderates all comments. Comments that are abusive or off-topic will not be posted to the site. Excessively long comments may be moderated as well. Bloomberg cannot facilitate requests to remove comments or explain individual moderation decisions.