Joe Nocera, Columnist

Idea Theft Is Hard to Prove. That's Good.

A writer accuses another of stealing his idea. Let's try to get to the bottom of the story.

Life is full of coincidences.

Photographer: John Moore/Getty Images
Lock
This article is for subscribers only.

I've had in my possession for awhile now a draft of a novel written by a masters-degree candidate at the University of Virginia. Titled "The Bold Harpooner," it was written in 2004 when the student was 29.

Although the manuscript is a long way from being a polished novel, aficionados of literary fiction will recognize its main characters, starting with a talented shortstop named Henry Skrimshander, who helps turn tiny Westish College's perennially inept baseball team into a band of baseball-playing brothers. His gay, cultured roommate, Owen, is a reserve on the team who Skrimshander badly injures with an errant throw, an act that drives much of the plot.