Cathy O'Neil, Columnist

That Health Tracker Could Cost You

Sometimes, big data and private insurance shouldn't mix.

Profiling device?

Photographer: Chris Ratcliffe/Bloomberg
Lock
This article is for subscribers only.

Using big data to improve health might seem like a great idea. The way private insurance works, though, it could end up making sick people -- or even those perceived as likely to become sick -- a lot poorer.

Suppose a company offers you an insurance discount and a free Fitbit if you agree to share your data and submit to a yearly physical. You're assured that the data will be used only in aggregate, never tied back to specific identities.