Kathryn Anne Edwards, Columnist

The American Worker Has Lost All Leverage

Return-to-office mandates are the most visible, but not the only, evidence that the balance of power has shifted back to employers.

The balance has shifted in the workforce. 

Photographer: Hulton Archive via Getty Images

Lock
This article is for subscribers only.

Judging by the 4.1% unemployment rate, the US labor market would appear to be thriving. Most any economist would say this is about as good as it gets, implying the economy is at or near or near full employment. Well, that’s one way to look at it. Another is via the hiring rate, which is sending a very concerning signal - and one that suggests a reversal of recent fortunes for the American worker.

That measure has been falling, dropping to 3.3% in November, a level that signals the labor market is in a deep recession. Yes, recession. Aside from a single month at the start of the pandemic, the hiring rate suggests that the labor market has not been this weak since it was struggling to crawl out of the deep 2007-2009 recession caused by the global financial crisis, according to Bureau of Labor Statistics.