Max Hastings, Columnist

Taking Crimea From Putin Has Become ‘Operation Unthinkable’

Winston Churchill learned the hard way that dealing militarily with Russians requires some unpalatable trade-offs. 

Bulldog and Uncle Joe.

Photographer: Hulton Archive via Getty Images

Lock
This article is for subscribers only.

It is hard to alter facts, reverse realities. This is almost as true in geopolitics as in science. I passionately support Ukraine’s battle for survival against Russian aggression. For almost a year, however, I have been arguing that heedless of where justice lies, and no matter how long the war continues, it remains militarily unlikely that Russian President Vladimir Putin can be dispossessed of Crimea, nor probably of the eastern Donbas region.

Russia can boast centuries of history, and considerable success, as an armed robber — sometimes on a continental scale. The most conspicuous example dates from 1945. By the end of World War II, British Prime Minister Winston Churchill was in no doubt that Soviet leader Josef Stalin was a monster, morally indistinguishable from Adolf Hitler.