Amity Shlaes & Matthew Denhart, Columnists

Republicans Shouldn’t Be Democrats-Lite

GOP senators offering plans to recapture the political center should study history. Spoiler alert: It won’t give them much comfort.

Remember him?

Source: AFP via Getty Images

Lock
This article is for subscribers only.

Republicans seem to be toying with the notion that the best way to erase the taint left by the Jan. 6 Capitol riot would be to shift toward the political center and offer Democrat Lite. The Republican Party took a similar politics-driven approach to economics after an earlier scandal, Watergate. The shift to the center failed then and will fail again.

Senator Mitt Romney of Utah has offered up a new Family Security Act that would supply child allowances of $4,200 per child each year to families, going down to $3,000 when the child turns six. Some of the particulars are disconcertingly precise, bespeaking an obsession with social engineering — why not age four, or age seven? — and the plan is so expensive that it envisions eliminating other tax benefits, some of which may be important to families.