Skip to content
Subscriber Only
Opinion
Andy Mukherjee

Modi’s Plan to Make a Singapore in Gujarat Has Fallen Flat

Investors aren’t coming to India’s new international financial center, built on a patch of wilderness in the prime minister’s home state.

Passengers sit inside a bus adorned with advertising in Gujarat International Finance Tec-City, known as Gift City, in Gujarat, India, in 2017.

Passengers sit inside a bus adorned with advertising in Gujarat International Finance Tec-City, known as Gift City, in Gujarat, India, in 2017.

Photographer: Dhiraj Singh/Bloomberg

When Singapore set up an international financial hub in the late 1960s, the city-state was thinking both fast and slow — seizing an immediate opportunity, and opening a path to long-term economic development. Half a century later, India is attempting something similar in Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s home state of Gujarat. But without much thought going into what exactly it’s building, for whom and for what purpose, all it may get is a casino for the local rich. 

For Singapore, the British pound’s 1967 devaluation was the moment of reckoning. For one thing, it raised the profile of Dick van Oenen, a Dutch trader who had made a “significant windfall” for both his employer — Bank of America — and for the newly independent city-state from that abrupt 14% change. But beyond the immediate cash, Singapore saw a broader canvas.