Skip to content
Subscriber Only
Opinion
Noah Smith

New York and San Francisco Can’t Assume They’ll Bounce Back

America’s big cities were beginning to struggle even before the pandemic led some residents to flee.

No bright lights here.

No bright lights here.

Photographer: ANGELA WEISS/AFP

Big cities are taking a big hit from the coronavirus pandemic. Statistics from employment search giant Indeed show that major U.S. metropolitan areas have lost a larger percentage of jobs, and have experienced greater rises in unemployment, than smaller metros. Especially hard-hit have been so-called superstar cities such as San Francisco, New York and Seattle:

Housing markets tell the same story. Rents in superstar cities have plunged, often by double-digit percentages. This is due in part to the reduced ability of residents to pay, but also because of wealthy people fleeing cities like San Francisco and Manhattan for (literally) greener pastures.