Skip to content
Subscriber Only
Opinion
Chris Bryant

Tesla's Overexcited Fans Should Cool Down a Little

Elon Musk’s electric car company has shown resilience during the pandemic but its share price jump this week has been over the top.

Future stuff.

Future stuff.

Photographer: FREDERIC J. BROWN/AFP

Back when Tesla Inc. delivered 95,000 cars to customers during the spring quarter of 2019, the stock price was languishing at about $235 and Elon Musk’s electric car company was valued at “only” $40 billion. Fast forward a year and the shares are now priced at more than $1,200. With a market capitalization of $224 billion, Tesla has surpassed Toyota Motor Corp. as the world’s most valuable automaker.

Yet in the second quarter of 2020, Tesla delivered 91,000 vehicles — about 5% fewer than the same period last year. That’s pretty underwhelming for a company whose fans view it as a fast-growing technology company in the mold of Amazon.com Inc., rather than a sluggish metal-bashing carmaker. So how is the massive recent jump in its market value justified?