Skip to content
Subscriber Only
Opinion
Noah Smith

High-Speed Rail Is Going Nowhere Fast in the U.S.

Bullet trains usually are money losers and make little sense for America’s sprawling, car-oriented landscape.

Probably not coming to the U.S. anytime soon.

Probably not coming to the U.S. anytime soon.

Photographer: AFP/Getty Images

Some leaders in the U.S. are intent on reviving the old dream of high-speed rail. Senator Bernie Sanders is proposing $607 billion for a new high-speed train network as part of his Green New Deal. Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez included it in her own plan earlier this year. On Twitter, Sanders’s political allies sing the praises of high-speed rail systems such as China’s.

High-speed rail puts an optimistic, futuristic face on an economic agenda that might otherwise seem mainly about sacrifice and belt-tightening. It’s high-tech, beautiful and iconic. It would be a substitute for regional air travel and road trips, and reduce carbon emissions. And it’s an area where the U.S. genuinely lags other countries. Anyone who has experienced the speed and convenience of traveling from city to city by bullet train in Japan or France will understand the appeal.