Stephen L. Carter, Columnist

Pete Buttigieg’s Plan to Politicize the Supreme Court

How will letting the parties appoint justices improve the court’s reputation for nonpartisanship?

How many justices should work here?

Photographer: Al Drago/Bloomberg
Lock
This article is for subscribers only.

Pete Buttigieg seems like a sensible fellow. The South Bend mayor and Democratic presidential candidate, who has become the latest media darling, has interesting ideas. And if progressives worry that he shows a troubling tendency to think for himself, maybe that’s a point in his favor.1

But whatever Buttigieg’s virtues, his ideas about how to fix the Supreme Court are bad. As in really, really bad.