Megan McArdle, Columnist

Plea Bargains Are a Travesty. There's Another Way.

Better to apply fewer laws more consistently than to continue the U.S.’s current “randomized draconianism.”

Jail just ain't what it used to be.

Source: Three Lions/Getty Images
Lock
This article is for subscribers only.

The justice system is no longer set up to provide an innocent man his day in court. It is a machine for producing plea bargains in industrial quantities.

It can operate no other way, because the volume of cases is far larger than the court system can actually handle. So instead of trials that take a long time and cost a lot of money but ideally separate the guilty from the innocent, we have become dependent on an assembly line where the accused go in at one end and come out the other a (relatively) short time later -- as convicted criminals, regardless of their guilt or innocence, but with shorter sentences than they would have faced if convicted at trial and with smaller lawyers’ bills than they would have faced if they had gone to trial.