Noah Smith, Columnist

Decline of the U.S. Middle Class

Downwardly mobile and not happy about it.

I never thought of myself that way before.

Photographer: Thomas Trutschel/Getty Images
Lock
This article is for subscribers only.

As the presidential primary season continues, much has been made of the appeal that candidates Donald Trump and Bernie Sanders hold for the angry, disaffected working class. Everyone seems to agree that this group is in trouble, and needs serious help.

But which Americans exactly are part of the working class? There is no set definition. You can define class by wealth, but a young worker starting out on Wall Street and earning relatively little is hardly lower-class. You can define it by income, although that will be distorted by local differences in the cost of living, and by age (retirees have little income but usually more wealth). You also can define it by educational status.