They Pledged Not to Prosecute Abortions. The Reality Is Tougher

  • Some discretion on bringing charges, but bans still pose peril
  • Florida state attorney fired after refusing to enforce new law

A woman waits for her appointment to receive an abortion at a clinic in West Palm Beach, Florida, in July.

Photographer: Chandan Khanna/AFP/Getty Images

Lock
This article is for subscribers only.

When the US Supreme Court toppled the constitutional right to abortion, some prosecutors in cities and counties across the country vowed to refrain from enforcing new state-imposed bans on the procedure. Such promises may be hard to keep.

Just ask Andrew Warren, the twice-elected state attorney in Hillsborough County, Florida, a state where abortion is now illegal after 15 weeks of pregnancy. In June, after the Supreme Court ruling, Warren joined a group of prosecutors and some state attorneys general in a written pledge not to pursue criminal charges in abortion cases. By August, he was out of a job.