Skip to content

ESG Investors Getting Trounced in Global Credit Market Rout

  • Sustainable debt has underperformed regular bonds in selloff
  • ESG bonds started out more expensive, got hit by rising rates
ArcelorMittal SA's Reduced Carbon Steel Plant
Photographer: Valeria Mongelli/Bloomberg
Updated on

The recent credit market selloff has been particularly hard on sustainable debt, challenging the popular premise that investors can do well and do good at the same time.

A Bloomberg index of environmental, social and governance debt has lagged a global bond benchmark by about 64 basis points over the past year. In Europe, which dominates the $4 trillion market, green corporate bonds have slumped 6.7% so far this year, more than the 6.1% loss for normal debt. China high-grade corporate green bonds underperformed non-green peers in the first quarter while in the U.S., green bonds modestly outperformed like-for-like counterparts, according to Morgan Stanley.