Modi's Election Budget May Push India's Interest Rates Higher

Updated on
  • Ahead of crucial elections, Modi goes big on rural spending
  • But Feb. 1 budget means India misses its fiscal deficit target
ANZ Chief Economist for Southeast Asia and India Sanjay Mathur discusses India’s economy and budget.

India’s Narendra Modi delivered an election year budget focused on tamping down rural discontent ahead of crucial elections, spending that could prompt the central bank to raise interest rates in the coming months.

With less than a week to go before the Reserve Bank of India meets to decide on policy, Finance Minister Arun Jaitley unveiled a budget that opens the taps for impoverished farmers, guaranteeing higher minimum crop prices and more spending on infrastructure projects in India’s vast rural hinterland.

That may prompt some in the six-member monetary policy committee to turn more hawkish. More than half of the economists surveyed by Bloomberg expect the RBI to hold rates at 6 percent through this year, but in the swaps market, investors are pricing in a hike to 6.5 percent before the end of 2018.

"Improving growth prospects, rising inflation and lingering fiscal slippage risks all point towards tighter monetary policy this year," said Priyanka Kishore, lead Asia economist at Oxford Economics in Singapore. "We are penciling in two rate hikes."

What Our Economists Say ...

India’s Finance Minister Arun Jaitley delivered a pre-election budget aimed at boosting rural incomes but at the cost of a larger-than-expected deficit -- likely confirming the central bank’s hawkish bias.

Read More: Indian Budget Deficit Spells Hawkish RBI, Crimped Capex
Indian Budget Deficit Spells Hawkish RBI, Crimped Capex

-- Abhishek Gupta of Bloomberg Economics

Modi’s Bharatiya Janata Party faces elections in eight Indian states this year and federal elections in the first half of 2019.

"The finance minister fails the fiscal consolidation test and this failure will have serious consequences," Congress leader Palaniappan Chidambaram said. 

Already, sovereign bond yields have spiked to their highest since June 2016, boding ill for the government’s borrowing plans and interest payments. A sustained rise in yields could also see banks raise lending rates, a move that could choke a nascent recovery in Asia’s third-largest economy.

Various high-frequency indicators show an economic recovery will gather pace over the next few quarters. That is likely to see a narrowing in the output gap and possibly higher rates.

‘Fanning Inflation’

“We see this budget fanning inflation with its focus on stoking consumption and at a time when oil is surging amid hardening global yields, that will change the narrative for the RBI’s monetary policy,” said Naveen Singh, head of fixed-income trading at ICICI Securities Primary Dealership Ltd. in Mumbai. “That’s what’s worrying the bond market most.”

The yield on sovereign bonds due January 2028 jumped 18 basis points to 7.61 percent on Thursday.

The government hopes this budget will alleviate discontent in the countryside, while creating desperately needed jobs.

However the spending boost means India missed its fiscal deficit target and disappointed investors with a long-term capital gains tax on equity investments. And while complex initiatives -- from boosting aquaculture to health care -- may not materialize fast enough to alter electoral sentiment, the budget suggests Modi’s government is attempting to balance deficit targets while not going all out with election freebies.

Pause Button

India breaches fiscal deficit targets

Source: Budget documents

Deficit for FY18 and FY19 are estimates

"It’s not a budget that’s too populist, it doesn’t look like they’ve thrown caution to the wind," said Reshmi Khurana of Kroll, a risk consultancy. "I don’t think it’s actually going to trickle down to the point where this means he sweeps elections."

The budget, as expected, focused heavily on rural India after a voter backlash in Modi’s home state of Gujarat.

The depth of anger across India was underscored by a recent survey suggesting "clear rumblings of discontent" among not just farmers, but traders and shopkeepers who traditionally support the BJP.

"These wide-ranging measures will help to consolidate rural support for the BJP in upcoming elections," said Rajiv Biswas, Asia-Pacific chief economist for IHS Markit Ltd., adding the BJP is concerned they might still "need the support of coalition partners to pursue his reform agenda.”

— With assistance by Kartik Goyal

    Before it's here, it's on the Bloomberg Terminal.