Long-Dreaded Amazon Threat to Drug Middlemen Draws CloserBy and
Benefit-manager stocks steady after sliding on new venture
Brash effort looks to reorder health system to contain costs
A day that prescription-drug middlemen had long feared finally arrived.
The industry awoke to the news Tuesday that Amazon.com Inc. was joining with Berkshire Hathaway Inc. and JPMorgan Chase & Co. to form a new health-care business, in an attempt by three of the world’s best-known companies to contain the spiraling cost of keeping their U.S. workers healthy.
Other groups of big employers have tried to improve worker health care in the past, but none have dethroned the pharmacy-benefit managers who drug companies and some lawmakers claim aren’t transparent about the pricing deals they strike on behalf of health plans, and about how much money they keep for themselves.
The new partnership has the potential to be one of the most ambitious employer efforts to date to control health expenses. While the companies provided few details, their combined clout and expertise in technology and finance could be used to bring drastic changes to the way prescription drugs are paid for, according to analysts.
“They could completely cut out the middlemen here,” said Pratap Khedkar, a managing principal at the health consulting firm ZS Associates. By doing so, Amazon, Berkshire and JPMorgan could gain more control over their spending and save money pharmacy-benefit managers currently consume, he said.
‘A Bit Arrogant’
Health costs have been an increasing burden for workers and businesses in the U.S., where about half the population gets health insurance through work. On average, 8.3 percent of total compensation costs for civilian workers went to health care in 2017, up from 7.3 percent in 2004, according to U.S. government data.
Change is likely to be slow in arriving. The companies outlined few concrete steps in their announcement, and making big changes to the entrenched, inefficient U.S. health system will likely prove more complicated than Jeff Bezos and Warren Buffett imagine, some health experts say.
“It is a bit arrogant to think three big firms are going to come in and kind of re-invent health care,” said Zack Cooper, an economist at Yale School of Public Health. “It is like health care companies saying they don’t like their telephones or computers so they are going to re-invent the IT industry.”
Late Tuesday, the Wall Street Journal cited an anonymous source saying that the current focus of the venture is helping existing vendors work better and not replacing them. But it also noted that a December document had criticized the role of the middlemen and discussed taking over their functions.
After falling on Tuesday, shares of PBMs were mixed on Wednesday. Express Scripts shares were down less than one percent to $78.99 at 11:08 a.m. New York time. CVS was up less than one percent to $80.64, and UnitedHealth was also up less than one percent, to $238.67.
The pact isn’t the first time that corporations have pledged to upend the system. The Health Transformation Alliance, a group of 46 large employers launched two years ago to fix the health-care system, negotiated better drug contracts with CVS Health Corp. and UnitedHealth Group Inc.’s OptumRx, two of the largest pharmacy-benefits managers. It says the new contracts should save its members who use them 15 percent a year in drug costs.
But the new venture unveiled by the trio of corporate titans could have the opportunity to do something far more drastic, such as bargain directly with drugmakers on top-selling drugs, or create an online bidding system to transparently negotiate drug prices, experts said. That could erode an important source of profits for pharmacy-benefits managers.
The prospect of Amazon entering the health-care industry has had retailers, drugmakers and insurance companies looking over their shoulders since last fall, when reports emerged that Internet retailer had gathered up pharmacy wholesaler licenses in more than a dozen states.
For their part, pharmacy-benefits managers have said they save employers billions and that their clients have the ability to do audits to confirm they are getting all the promised drug discounts. The companies say they welcome the efforts of Amazon, Berkshire and JPMorgan.
The announcement “is clear recognition that the healthcare system needs to continue to create and deliver meaningful value,” Express Scripts, which currently manages drug benefits for Amazon.com, said in a statement. CVS, which manages pharmacy benefits for JPMorgan, said in an email that the new organization “seems to share our goal of improving consumer health while reducing costs.”
UnitedHealth Group declined to comment.
In the meantime, the middlemen are trying to remake themselves. With the Amazon threat looming, CVS agreed last year to take over insurance giant Aetna Inc., while Anthem Inc. said it will set up its own pharmacy-benefits manager after the insurer’s relationship with Express Scripts fell apart in a dispute over pricing.
— With assistance by John Tozzi