Canada Raises Alarm on Trump Leaving Nafta

Updated on
  • Loonie, peso fall ahead of next round of talks in Montreal
  • U.S. bristles after Canada escalates trade fight at WTO
Bloomberg’s Josh Wingrove reports on the status of Nafta talks.

Canadian government officials said there’s an increasing likelihood U.S. President Donald Trump will give six-months’ notice to withdraw from Nafta, dragging down the loonie, yields on government bonds and Mexico’s peso.

The officials, speaking Wednesday on condition they not be identified, declined to say whether they think the odds of Trump following through on repeated threats to quit the pact now exceed 50 percent. A White House official, speaking on background, said there hasn’t been any change in the president’s position on the North American Free Trade Agreement.

The comments have raised worries the Nafta countries -- the U.S., Canada and Mexico, who trade more than $1 trillion annually -- are further apart on coming to an agreement than feared. The Canadian officials said a U.S. withdrawal notice could come at any time, and Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s government is considering all options related to industries that would be most affected.

Trump withdrawing from Nafta “was always a risk, but that risk is clearly more elevated now,” said Brian DePratto, senior economist at Toronto-Dominion Bank.

Trade relations between the two countries have taken a dramatic turn this week, with Canada escalating its spat with the U.S. by filing a World Trade Organization complaint over American duties against Canada and other countries. U.S. Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer called that a “broad and ill-advised attack.”

Officials from the three nations are maneuvering to frame the debate ahead of the sixth round of Nafta talks in Montreal starting Jan. 23, when negotiators are expected to tackle contentious issues they bypassed at discussions last month in Washington. Canada has been pushing Nafta’s U.S. defenders to speak up to save the pact -- the officials’ comments Wednesday may add domestic pressure on Trump to not issue the withdrawal notice.

The three countries have already planned a subsequent round of talks in February in Mexico City, two people familiar with plans said.

Market Reaction

Implied odds that Bank of Canada Governor Stephen Poloz will raise interest rates next week dropped to as low as 57 percent immediately after news that Trump may withdraw, from 84 percent just before, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. The odds later rebounded to about 80 percent after the White House official comments.

Shares of companies considered most at risk declined. Kansas City Southern fell as much as 4.6 percent after the report, its biggest loss in more than eight months. Canadian Pacific Railway Ltd. sank 3.3 percent in Toronto and CSX Corp. slipped 1.7 percent. General Motors Co. slid as much as 3.3 percent while auto-parts stocks also fell, paced by Lear Corp. Canada’s S&P/TSX Composite Index extended declines after the news, dropping as much as 0.6 percent. The index closed down 0.4 percent in Wednesday trading.

Read more about why killing Nafta might not be as easy as Trump thinks

The Canadian dollar fell 0.7 percent to C$1.2574 against the greenback at 4 p.m. in Toronto. The peso fell as much as 0.9 percent to 19.3963 per dollar, before rebounding later in the day. The rate on Canada’s two-year government bonds declined 6 basis points to 1.74 percent. The yield on 10-year debt was down four basis points to 2.16 percent.

“The market’s been too complacent regarding Nafta termination risk for too long,” said Bipan Rai, a Toronto-based foreign-exchange and macro strategist at Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce. “Outside of the Bank of Canada meeting next week, there should be upward pressure on USD/CAD as that premium increases into the next round.”

‘Cold Shoulder’

Talks to overhaul Nafta began in August. They have so far yielded little firm indication of whether a deal can be reached to update the pact, the Canadian officials said. 

Canada, along with Mexico, has so far rejected some of the Trump administration’s hardline demands and refused to offer counter-proposals -- and warned there won’t be a deal unless the U.S. puts water in its wine. The U.S. is insisting on a five-year automatic termination clause, stricter rules on autos, government procurement and dairy, and the overhaul or elimination of dispute panels.

Mexican Economy Minister Ildefonso Guajardo has said his country won’t negotiate under duress and will leave the table if the U.S. initiates the withdrawal process. The Canadian officials said Wednesday they weren’t sure how Mexico would react to any withdrawal notice but that Canada would keep negotiating after one was given. A withdrawal notice doesn’t mean Nafta would be killed -- a country can give notice and then not actually leave.

“What’s surprising to me is that everybody is so surprised. We knew the last round of talks ended with a very cold shoulder being given by the Americans to Canada and Mexico’s positions, and we heard from Trump saying we’ll probably have to pull out,” CIBC Chief Economist Avery Shenfeld said.

Shenfeld sees the loonie falling to 75 cents and Poloz slowing the pace of hikes if Trump ultimately quits. “What isn’t clear is whether six months down the road this means the end of Nafta, or does Congress stall, does Canada play for time? It certainly throws enough doubt on Nafta that it could affect capital spending plans this year.”

— With assistance by Maciej Onoszko, Eric Martin, Erik Hertzberg, Greg Quinn, Andrew Mayeda, and Justin Sink

    Before it's here, it's on the Bloomberg Terminal.