North Korea Wins Olympics Trip, But Discord Remains Over Nuclear Weapons

Updated on
  • South Korea talks stumble over call for denuclearization
  • Both sides agree on North Korea participating in Olympics
Bloomberg’s Stephen Engle reports on talks held between North and South Korea in the DMZ.

North Korea’s chief negotiator Ri Son Gwon struck a jovial tone as he sat down on Tuesday morning for his country’s first formal talks with South Korea in more than two years.

He joked about how the subzero temperatures reflected frosty ties and asked for the proceedings to be broadcast live -- a request South Korea turned down. A few hours later, South Korea announced that North Korea would join the Olympics next month in Pyeongchang, a ski town near their shared border.

Yet as the day wore on, and South Korea proposed talks on ending North Korea’s nuclear weapons program, the mood appeared to sour. Ri issued a “strong complaint” that Seoul dared to even raise the possibility of denuclearization at such an early stage. The subject is likely to arise again Wednesday when South Korean President Moon Jae-in holds a press briefing.

North Korea’s participation in the Winter Games starting Feb. 9 brings potential benefits to the troubled Korean peninsula, which has been divided for more than 70 years. Kim Jong Un gets the opportunity to ease the global pressure on his isolated regime, while Moon can bet on a more peaceful Olympics and claim a victory in his push for dialogue.

Read more: An explainer on the Korea talks

But the long-term dilemma remains: North Korea sees its nuclear weapons -- and the ability to use them against the U.S. -- as the only thing protecting against an American invasion. At the same time, U.S. President Donald Trump views Kim’s rapidly expanding nuclear arsenal as an intolerable threat, one that must be eradicated by war if necessary.

All of North Korea’s “high-end strategic weapons” are targeted at the U.S., Ri said at the conclusion of the talks Tuesday, according to South Korean media.

Ahead of the talks, the U.S. and Japan sought reassurances from Moon that he would continue to press Kim over his weapons program. After North Korea in recent months tested its most powerful nuclear device yet and shot off missiles capable of reaching the U.S., the United Nations imposed sanctions restricting oil imports and cutting off about 90 percent of its export revenue.

Cho Myoung-gyon and Ri Son Gwon shake hands in the Demilitarized Zone on Jan. 9.

Photographer: KPPA/Pool via Bloomberg

The U.S. welcomes the talks on the Winter Olympics, the State Department said in a statement Tuesday. The administration is in close contact with South Korean officials, who will ensure North Korea’s participation in the games “does not violate the sanctions imposed by the UN Security Council” over its “unlawful nuclear and ballistic missile programs.”

‘Vicious Sanctions’

In his annual New Year’s Day address, Kim blasted the “vicious sanctions” and American efforts to isolate North Korea on the world stage. He also taunted Trump, boasting of a credible nuclear deterrent that would prevent the U.S. “from starting an adventurous war.”

In pitching talks with South Korea, Kim sought to exacerbate tensions in Seoul’s alliance with the U.S. He called for Koreans to solve their own problems, a sentiment repeated in their joint statement on Tuesday.

For Moon, it’s a tempting message. Earlier this year, as U.S. officials signaled they would tolerate casualties in Seoul in a preemptive strike against North Korea, the South Korean leader pledged to prevent war at all costs.

South Korea doesn’t want to see the U.S. cut a deal with Pyongyang that freezes its nuclear program in a way that eliminates a threat to Washington while leaving Seoul exposed, according to Youngshik Bong, a researcher at Yonsei Institute for North Korean Studies in Seoul.

Hwasong-15 missile launch on Nov. 29.

Photographer: KCNA/AFP via Getty Images

‘Same Page’

“Then South Korea will be left cold and dry, with North Korea still possessing nuclear weapons and missiles,” Bong said.

For now, the U.S. remains on the sidelines, even as Trump on Saturday suggested he could meet Kim under the right conditions. He called the talks over the Olympics “a big start.”

Despite the frictions over nuclear weapons, the two sides agreed Tuesday to hold a military dialogue and resolve problems through negotiations. They plan to hold another round of talks, though haven’t yet agreed on the date.

At the same time, Kim had another message for the U.S. on Tuesday. A commentary in the state-run Minju Joson said “it’ll be wise for the U.S. to face reality” and accept North Korea as a nuclear state.

“Kim Jong Un wants time,” Gordon Chang, author of "Nuclear Showdown: North Korea Takes on the World,” told Bloomberg Television earlier Tuesday. “He doesn’t want the U.S. to strike his nuclear and missile facilities, so really what he is trying to do is make sure the status quo continues. And one of the ways to do that is to create optimism in the world.”

— With assistance by Nick Wadhams

(Updates with U.S. comment in eighth paragraph.)
    Before it's here, it's on the Bloomberg Terminal. LEARN MORE