U.S. Sees ‘Four or Five’ Ways to Resolve North Korean Crisis

  • Some options ‘are uglier than others,’ H.R. McMaster says
  • North Korea could target planes in international airspace: Ri

North Korea Escalates Rhetoric Against U.S.

The U.S. has gamed out four or five different scenarios for how the crisis with North Korea will be resolved, and “some are uglier than others,” National Security Adviser H.R. McMaster said as tensions remain high between the two countries.

While McMaster said the threat from Pyongyang is “much further advanced” than anticipated and the Pentagon said the president has a “deep arsenal” to draw upon if needed, U.S. officials dismissed North Korean Foreign Minister Ri Yong Ho’s comment that President Donald Trump’s warnings to Pyongyang at the United Nations amounted to a declaration of war.

Ri Yong Ho

Photographer: Jewel Samad/AFP via Getty Images

“We’ve not declared war on North Korea,” White House spokeswoman Sarah Sanders said Monday. “And frankly the suggestion of that is absurd. We continue to seek the peaceful denuclearization of the Korean Peninsula.”

Both governments have said “all options” are on the table in dealing with the tensions. Defense Secretary Jim Mattis, speaking in India on Tuesday, said the U.S. wants to keep engagement with North Korea in the diplomatic realm as long as possible.

But Ri escalated tensions with his remark on Monday in New York that North Korea would be within its rights to shoot down U.S. warplanes flying in international airspace. That startled markets, coming just days after the Pentagon sent planes near North Korea’s border.

“The UN Charter acknowledges member states’ right of self-defense,” Ri said. “As the United States has declared a war, even though its strategic bombers don’t cross our border, we will come to own all rights to respond for self-defense including shooting down its planes at any time.”

B-1B Lancer bombers, based in Guam, and F-15C Eagle fighter escorts from Okinawa, Japan, traveled the farthest north of the demilitarized zone any U.S. fighter or bomber aircraft have flown off North Korea’s coast this century, Pentagon spokeswoman Dana White said last week in an emailed statement.

North Korea raised security on its eastern coastline after being surprised by the bombers, which weren’t caught by its radar, Yonhap News reported, citing the head of the intelligence committee of South Korea’s parliament.

U.S. Air Force B-1B Lancer bombers fly with F-35B and South Korean Air Force F-15K jets during a drill on Sept. 18.

Photographer: South Korean Defense Ministry via Getty Images

Military analysts say any conflict between the U.S. and North Korea would risk a devastating attack by Pyongyang on the South Korean capital Seoul.

“There’s not a ‘precision strike’ that solves the problem,” McMaster, an Army lieutenant general, said at an event in Washington hosted by the Institute for the Study of War. “There’s not a military blockade that can solve the problem. What we hope to do is avoid war, but we cannot discount that possibility.”

A QuickTake Explainer: Why New U.S. Sanctions on North Korea Could Bite

Follow the Trump Administration’s Every Move

McMaster declined to comment on the extent to which North Korea’s deeply-buried nuclear program was vulnerable to U.S. military strikes -- an assessment made of Iran before the 2015 framework agreement designed to stop its nuclear program.

He acknowledged that every military option assumed a reaction from North Korea that endangered South Korean citizens, adding it’s “foremost in our minds.” That danger “is certainly taken into consideration in all our planning and war gaming, table-top exercise efforts,” McMaster said.

Kim Jong Un has accelerated his ballistic missile and nuclear weapons testing program. In response, the U.S. has led two recent rounds of UN sanctions on the regime, winning support from China, North Korea’s top trading partner, and Russia.

The U.S. is “just now” beginning to see initial results of those sanctions, McMaster said, adding it’s in China’s best interest to ensure compliance with the restrictions. China would face “the prospect of a re-arming” in the region and enhanced military activities in South Korea and Japan. “There’s a lot that’s changed,” he said.

Read a QuickTake Q&A on what U.S.-North Korea hostilities could look like

In addition to the UN sanctions, Trump announced an executive order on Sept. 21 that allows the U.S. to impose a full trade and financial embargo on non-U.S. banks, companies and people who do business with North Korea.

The Pentagon said its most recent bomber and fighter exercises were meant to underscore “the seriousness with which we take DPRK’s reckless behavior,” White said last week, using the initials for North Korea’s formal name. “This mission is a demonstration of U.S. resolve and a clear message that the President has many military options.”

Lu Kang, a spokesman for China’s foreign ministry said assertiveness from both sides would only increase the risk of confrontation.

“We have witnessed a lot of saber rattling recently on the Korean peninsula,” he said. “We hope the U.S. and DPRK politicians can realize that resorting to military means will never be a viable way out for this issue.”

U.S. stocks initially fell and bonds gained after Ri’s comments, while the yen strengthened and gold climbed.

North Korea has responded to each round of UN sanctions with additional weapons tests, including a nuclear explosion -- its most powerful so far -- in early September that caused an earthquake with a magnitude of about 6.3.

President Trump discusses North Korea before the United Nations General Assembly. on Sept. 19.

(Source: Bloomberg)

Trump, in his debut speech to the UN General Assembly on Sept. 19, threatened to “totally destroy” North Korea if it attacked the U.S. or its allies. He mocked Kim with a taunt he’d first used on Twitter days before, saying: “Rocket Man is on a suicide mission for himself and his regime.”

Ri, responding from the UN podium last week, said: “The very reason the DPRK had to possess nuclear weapons is because of the U.S.” North Korea’s state media also issued a statement Saturday from the National Peace Committee of Korea describing Trump as “wicked” and “a rabid dog.”

‘Insulted Me’

North Korea and South Korea, a key U.S. ally, have technically remained at war since the 1950s, with Kim’s regime saying an armistice agreement is invalid. On Sept. 22, Kim issued an unprecedented statement for a North Korean leader aimed at Trump, using the first person in several parts to attack the U.S. president.

“Now that Trump has denied the existence of and insulted me and my country in front of the eyes of the world and made the most ferocious declaration of a war in history that he would destroy the DPRK, we will consider with seriousness exercising of a corresponding, highest level of hard-line countermeasure in history,” Kim wrote in comments carried by state-run media.

In 1969, President Richard Nixon considered tactical nuclear strikes after North Korea shot down a U.S. reconnaissance plane, according to documents declassified in 2010 and published by the National Security Archive.

— With assistance by Andy Sharp, Kanga Kong, David Tweed, and Peter Martin

    Before it's here, it's on the Bloomberg Terminal.
    LEARN MORE