As Good as It Gets: Iron Ore Risks a Reversal as China CoolsBy
Weakening steel output, rising mine supply may roll back gains
Capital Economics, Citigroup among forecasters seeing declines
Iron ore in the $70s a ton may be as good as it gets for some time. After rallying hard in June and July, the commodity may see its gains unravel over the second half as steel production in China eases back from a record pace just as global miners pump up volumes.
The robust demand that’s supported gains may fade as steelmakers start to dial back output, according to Capital Economics Ltd., which came out first among forecasters in the second quarter, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. Others expecting a drop include Citigroup Inc., Sucden Financial Ltd., Axiom Capital Management Inc. and hedge fund Academia Capital.
“There was some fundamental support for iron ore’s rally, namely strong growth in China’s steel output,” Caroline Bain, chief commodities economist at Capital Economics, said by email. “Stocks at China’s ports are now stubbornly high and if, as seems likely, steel production and demand eases back later in the year, then we see iron ore prices coming under renewed pressure.”
Iron ore has surged on sustained demand from China, with mills benefiting from rising product prices and strong profit margins after the government shuttered some capacity. Remaining producers are making record volumes, helping absorb rising supplies from Brazil and Australia and aiding miners including Rio Tinto Group and Vale SA. Even those who aren’t deeply pessimistic on iron, such as Clarksons Platou Securities Inc., do expect some retracement.
‘Far Too Bearish’
“While we believe the market is far too bearish on iron ore, we don’t expect prices to stay here,” Jeremy Sussman, managing director for metals & mining, said in an email, predicting a drop to about $60 in the final quarter and holding at that level through 2018. Among supportive factors are the supply reforms in China, as well as continued discipline from the so-called Big 4 -- Rio and Vale, plus BHP Billiton Ltd. and Fortescue Metals Group Ltd., he said.
Benchmark spot ore with 62 percent content delivered to Qingdao dropped to $72.97 a dry ton on Wednesday, declining for a fourth day, according to Metal Bulletin Ltd. The raw material rebounded from a low near $50 a ton in mid-June to hit $76.68 last week, the highest level since April.
Data this week from China showed signs of a slowdown. Industrial output, investment and consumption all slowed, and property -- a key driver of steel demand -- is also losing momentum. Yao Wei, chief China economist at Societe Generale SA in Paris, said peak growth of the cycle “is behind us," citing a slump in housing sales growth, a leading indicator.
For now steel production is holding at unprecedented levels, with output in July at 74 million tons, up 10 percent from a year ago. Still, output from the top supplier typically slows in the second half, dropping off toward November.
Then, there are supplies. Shipments from top producers are seen at 313.6 million tons in the third quarter, up 5 percent on-year, Sanford C. Bernstein Ltd. said in a report this month. “Iron ore is just too plentiful,” Ed Morse, Citigroup’s head of commodities research, told Bloomberg TV on Tuesday.
Hedge fund Academia Capital says speculative buying has helped to boost raw materials including iron ore, and those gains may reverse as China’s growth slows, according to Ivan Szpakowski, chief investment officer. Separately, Axiom also expects iron to weaken, citing a new model in a report this week.
Iron ore is “currently well supported,” said Kash Kamal, an analyst at Sucden in London. Still, prices could soften, “especially on the most recent string of economic data coming out of China which saw fixed-asset investment and industrial production disappoint,” he said.