World’s Hottest Funds Make No Money for Most Managers in EuropeBy and
Vanguard data shows two-thirds of ETFs just aren’t big enough
ETF industry in the region to double by 2020, Morningstar Says
Being in the hottest part of the investment universe doesn’t necessarily pay.
Exchange-traded funds, or ETFs, based in Europe have doubled assets in the past five years to 550 billion euros ($584 billion), though the market remains so fragmented that less than a third of them are big enough to make money for the manager, based on figures from U.S. company Vanguard Group Inc.
The proliferation of ETFs means it will be a case of survival of the fittest as Europe catches up with the U.S., where the average size of a fund is about $1.4 billion compared with $260 million across the Atlantic. Managers are putting up with losses today because of the potential rewards if they attract money from new clients or rivals unable to compete.
“You are not going to be profitable unless you have massive scale,” said Paul Stratford, an executive director responsible for asset management at accounting firm EY in Edinburgh. “The players in that space are in for the long game. Competitors who are unable to make money will exit the market.”
ETFs allow customers to own entire baskets of stocks and bonds in a single security. Their popularity has soared along with other so-called passive investments because they’re typically cheaper than traditional mutual funds in a world of record-low interest rates and suppressed returns. Their assets have grown to more than $4 trillion globally since the original ETF, State Street Corp.’s SPDR, started in 1993.
In Europe, there are about 2,200 of the funds, more than 1,500 of which have less than $100 million, the threshold at which they typically start to make money, according to Andreas Zingg, head of distribution at Vanguard’s ETF business for continental Europe. At Vanguard, which has about 4 percent of the European market, a third of its 18 funds have less than that. They are among the newest and cheapest offerings.
BlackRock Inc., the world’s largest fund company, is the biggest seller of ETFs and controls almost half the market. A spokeswoman in London said nobody from BlackRock was available to comment or give details on the size of its funds.
Funds largely compete on price and need sufficient assets to generate the fees required to cover running costs. Niche funds, such as those linked to Sharia law, can charge higher fees and therefore be profitable with fewer assets, Zingg said from Zurich.
The smaller funds lack “all the great advantages of an ETF -- cost efficiency and liquidity,” said Zingg, whose company oversees $4 trillion globally.
A typical fee for an ETF is about 30 basis points in Europe, or 0.3 percent, less than half the 75 basis points for an actively managed mutual fund, according to data from Vanguard. So that means a customer would pay $3 for every $1,000 invested rather than $7.50. For European stock funds selecting the region’s biggest companies, research firm Morningstar Inc. put the average fee at 1.67 percent, or $16.70.
Companies want to offer a full range of funds to entice customers in an expanding market, a bit like running a supermarket, according to Kenneth Lamont, an analyst at Morningstar, which predicts European ETFs will exceed 1 trillion euros by 2020. Unlike in the U.S., fund managers in Europe also have to replicate products in different markets with varying tax and regulatory regimes.
The U.S. had 1,995 funds from 109 providers on three exchanges at the end of February, according to London-based research company ETFGI. Europe had 2,233 from from 58 providers across 25 exchanges in 21 countries, it said.
“If you launched a fund, you are anticipating growth in the industry, which is a fairly reasonable assumption,” Lamont said. “All of these providers are trying to position themselves to capture inflows as they come.”