United's Munoz Goes From Savior to Man on Hot Seat Real FastBy and
Former Coca-Cola executive throws fuel on social-media fire
CEO turned around airline only to spark global customer anger
For most of his 19-month tenure, United Continental Holdings Inc. Chief Executive Officer Oscar Munoz has cleaned up messes left behind by others. Now he’s mopping up a PR disaster that’s unfolded on his watch.
After United ordered a passenger forcibly removed from a plane in Chicago shortly before departure to make room for a United employee, Munoz’s initial response made the company a punch line on social media. He said United had to “re-accommodate’’ the man, who was bloodied in the encounter with security officials. In a subsequent letter to employees, the CEO called the customer “disruptive’’ and “belligerent’’ when he wouldn’t relinquish his seat.
“It’s sort of a self-immolation and makes you wonder about his choice as CEO,” said Jeffrey Sonnenfeld, senior associate dean for leadership studies at the Yale School of Management. He “worked at Coke and Pepsi and AT&T, and someone would have thought he had a better customer sensitivity.”
Almost 24 hours later, after global condemnation of the airline’s behavior had time to sink in, Munoz struck a far more contrite tone.
“The truly horrific event that occurred on this flight has elicited many responses from all of us: outrage, anger, disappointment,” Munoz said in a statement Tuesday. “I deeply apologize to the customer forcibly removed and to all the customers aboard. No one should ever be mistreated this way.”
Video posted to Facebook and Twitter showed the passenger as he was dragged out of his seat and down the aisle of the plane after refusing to give up his seat.
On Wednesday Munoz said the carrier no longer will rely on law enforcement to remove seated, paying customers. “This can never, will never, happen again on a United Airlines flight,” he said on ABC’s “Good Morning America.” The CEO said he hasn’t considered resigning.
He has committed the third-largest U.S. airline to “a thorough review” of its policies for handling oversold flights and vowed to report back to the public by April 30.
Yet the damage had already been done. With a few ill-chosen words, Munoz stoked the flames of an already raging social-media firestorm and squandered goodwill he had worked hard to generate by forging a turnaround plan since joining the company in September 2015. He has overseen a 23 percent stock rally since then, compared with 13 percent for the Bloomberg U.S. Airlines Index.
Previously known for his deft touch in rescuing United from a corruption scandal, weathering a proxy fight and winning unprecedented labor peace, now he’s the head of an airline that, for some passengers, has instantly become Public Enemy No. 1.
Some people said on United’s Facebook page that they would boycott the Chicago-based carrier. Others said on Twitter that they’d canceled their United-affiliated credit cards -- a key revenue source for airlines.
In China, a crucial part of United’s lucrative trans-Pacific network, the incident was a focus of social media and editorials in the state-controlled Global Times newspaper. The hashtag #UnitedForcesPassengerOffPlane was the top trending item on Sina Weibo, the equivalent of Twitter. The man who was removed, David Dao, appeared to be of Asian descent.
Delta Air Lines Inc. “is best-positioned to take share as it has focused Asia operations on China and away from Japan in recent years,” Bloomberg Intelligence analyst George Ferguson said in a note. Gains will be limited for American Airlines Group Inc., a distant No. 3, while the largest Chinese carriers will benefit the most, he said.
Several Middle Eastern carriers piled on to mock United, one of the principal critics of their rapid expansion. Dubai-based Emirates on Twitter lampooned United’s motto, urging passengers to “fly the friendly skies with a real airline.”
Dao was receiving treatment in a Chicago hospital for his injuries, according to a statement from lawyers who said they represent him. The lawyers sought a court order Wednesday in Chicago to preserve evidence, including surveillance videos, crew lists and other information, that could be used in litigation. A lawsuit hasn’t been filed.
For Munoz, the timing of the worldwide outcry is, at the very least, extremely awkward and at worst a serious setback for his overhaul of United, which suffered for years as the industry laggard in profitability and on-time performance. Munoz just last month was named “Communicator of the Year for 2017” by PRWeek. The public-relations industry publication said Munoz “has shown himself to be a smart, dedicated, and excellent leader who understands the value of communications.”
In 2015, Munoz took over as CEO from Jeff Smisek, who was ousted amid a federal investigation into ties between the carrier and the former chairman of the Port Authority of New York & New Jersey. The next month, Munoz suffered a heart attack and underwent a transplant in early 2016. He bounced back only to face a proxy challenge from two hedge funds. United named a new chairman and agreed to add board members approved by PAR Capital Management and Altimeter Capital Management.
Within months after the board tussle, Munoz had unveiled a $3.1 billion plan to cut costs and boost revenue, and he set the stage for labor peace for the first time since the 2010 merger with Continental Airlines that created the company. He also brought in new senior leadership including President Scott Kirby, who previously served in the same position at American. United’s market value this year surpassed that of American, which generates more in annual sales.
The Dao incident comes two weeks after United drew social-media scorn for enforcing its employee dress code for those who fly as non-revenue passengers, such as relatives of employees. Two young girls flying from Denver were told to change their leggings before boarding. In response, the airline then took efforts to tell “our regular customers” that “leggings are welcome.”
In his letter to United workers Monday night, the CEO said he stood behind employees and criticized the passenger for refusing to deplane. Sara Nelson, international president of the flight attendants union representing United, said the event was the most severe customer backlash she’d seen in 20 years on the job and was “completely unacceptable.” Still, employees were grateful to have a chief executive who “has their backs.”
“When something like this happens and people have to go to work and have order in their workplace to keep everyone safe, it can be incredibly demoralizing,” Nelson said. “Some credit needs to be given to him.”
— With assistance by Mary Schlangenstein, Sarah Kopit, and Paul Failla