Trump Poses Diplomatic Dilemma for May With White House Invite

  • Prime minister to discuss U.S.-U.K. trade during Jan. 27 visit
  • Needs to find common ground with ‘America first’ president

What's at Stake for U.K.'s May in Trump Meeting?

Being the first European leader through the door of Donald Trump’s White House is an honor that Theresa May worked hard to get. But it’s one that comes with a daunting set of challenges.

The British prime minister will visit Washington on Jan. 27, seven days after Trump took office. Her stated goal is to engage the new president on questions about the future of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization and Syria’s civil war. Her most important task is to nail down details of what a U.S.-U.K. trade deal would cover.

But what common ground can there be between a prime minister who sees herself as a champion of global free trade and a president who sees commerce as “other countries making our products, stealing our companies and destroying our jobs”? How does a woman with a Muslim in her Cabinet deal with a man who said he wanted to ban all adherents of Islam from entering the U.S.? Speaking on Sunday, May was keen the emphasize the positive.

“He’s already said to me that he wants to see a very strong relationship between the U.K. and the U.S. going into the future,” she told the BBC, before insisting that she would stand up to him. “Whenever there is something that I find unacceptable, I won’t be afraid to say that to Donald Trump.”

Diplomatic Restraint

The usual approach of British prime ministers to American presidents is to get as close to them as possible, whatever the differences of political allegiance. A shared ideology may have smoothed the way for Margaret Thatcher and Ronald Reagan, but Tony Blair didn’t let partisan disagreement stop him from joking about sharing toothpaste with George W. Bush. David Cameron and Barack Obama seemed to enjoy each other’s company and supplied one another with mutual political support when needed.

Trump is a different proposition. During his election campaign he was viewed from Britain as such an improbable candidate that politicians dropped their usual diplomatic restraint and publicly criticized him. Women marched to protest his inauguration in Britain’s cities, as well as America’s. Around 5 percent of Britain’s population is Muslim. An overly close public relationship could be politically painful at home for May.

She does have some cards to play. Trump has praised Britain’s decision to leave the European Union. If he sees Brexit as part of the same movement as Trumpism, that might compel him to be supportive of generous trade talks, whatever his rhetoric. Trump officials, speaking privately, believe their preliminary trade discussions with May’s government encouraged her to be more aggressive in exiting the EU.

Jeremy Corbyn, leader of the opposition Labour Party, was skeptical about the possibility of Trump offering a good deal. He described the inauguration speech as “America first, America only, America inward-looking,” and said it didn’t suggest that “Donald Trump is suddenly going to roll over and offer some kind of trade deal with Britain which doesn’t have strings attached.”

Buckingham Stay

By going enthusiastically to meet him, May also allows Trump to portray himself as someone taken seriously by other leaders. And she can offer him things that even a billionaire can’t buy, like a stay at Buckingham Palace as a guest of the Queen. The prime minister said on Sunday that the latter invitation was for the palace to announce, but dropped a strong hint that it would come this year.

Still, events in America are being watched closely in Britain, and lawmakers in May’s Conservative Party are already coming to their own conclusions about the new president. After Trump’s spokesman Sean Spicer attacked journalists for reporting the size of the crowds at Trump’s inauguration, Tory Johnny Mercer posted the clip on Twitter.

“Straight from Pyongyang,” he commented, referring to the capital of North Korea. “Day one; lost the plot.”

And Trump isn’t the only international leader May has to deal with. Britain sends more than twice as many export to the EU as the U.S., making a trade deal there far more important. EU leaders could resent her cozying up to someone who has predicted the break-up of the bloc and described it as “basically a vehicle for Germany.”

‘Tricky Dicky’

But there are signs that other leaders also accept the need to find middle ground with the president. Germany’s Angela Merkel told reporters over the weekend that she was planning to work at the relationship. “Even when there are differences of opinion, compromises and opportunities can best be found when working together with mutual respect,” she said.

So it could be that May’s insights into private talks with a man that few EU leaders have met give her something to talk about at the EU summit, which will be held in Malta next month.

“It’s not going to be easy dealing with a man who makes Tricky Dicky look like Honest Abe, and a joint press conference is going to be quite an ordeal for the prime minister,” Tim Bale, professor of politics and international relations at Queen Mary, University of London, said in an interview. “All she can do is pack her rictus grin in her hand luggage, and hope she and her team can get something half-way sensible from Trump’s team behind the scenes and from congressional Republicans.”

— With assistance by Scott Hamilton

    Before it's here, it's on the Bloomberg Terminal.
    LEARN MORE