Christmas Market Tragedy Hands Merkel Critics Line of Attack

  • German leader faces election-year challenge from populist AfD
  • Chancellor has toughened stances on migration amid pressure

Merkel: We Have to Assume This Was a Terror Attack

Chancellor Angela Merkel got an early taste of the kind of reception she can expect from her populist opponents after a truck careened into a Berlin Christmas market, killing 12 people in what her government said was probably a terror attack.

“These are Merkel’s dead,” Marcus Pretzell, chairman of the Alternative for Germany party in the western state of North Rhine-Westphalia, posted on Twitter, eliciting a chorus of rebuttals. A vice chairman of the Social Democrats, Ralf Stegner, called the comment “unbelievable and disgusting.”

Investigators on the scene at the Christmas market in Berlin on Dec. 19.

Photographer: Sean Gallup/Getty Images

The response from the anti-immigration party that’s polling in third place nationally underscores the pressure on the German leader to calm a jittery nation as investigators seek to piece together the background to the presumed attack in the capital.

Even if it turns out to be Islamic terrorism, it’s hard to predict what the consequences might be for the chancellor, according to Daniel Hamilton, executive director of the Center for Transatlantic Relations at the Johns Hopkins School of Advanced International Studies in Washington.

“Germany hasn’t had an attack like this that’s killed a lot of people in a long time, so clearly there will be pressure on her,” Hamilton said by phone. “But there will also be a sense that Europeans are in this together, that it’s a common threat.”

Pressure Pot

For Merkel, who will make a statement at 11 a.m. in Berlin, Monday’s tally of dead and injured may be a day of reckoning for her political future. While police were cautious in speculating on a motive, the chancellor’s hopes of winning a fourth term in federal elections next fall may not survive another public debate about the risks of terrorism and anxieties over an influx of over a million refugees since the beginning of 2015.

“Our worst fears are confirmed,” Stephan Meyer, a Bavarian lawmaker in the lower house allied with Merkel, told Bild newspaper.

Merkel’s Facebook page, which has about 2.3 million likes, the most of any German politician, was changed to a black background after the killings. Users flooded the site with hundreds of comments, many criticizing her for not making an immediate public statement, urging her to step down, or blaming her refugee policy for the attack.

While the overwhelming majority of posts were critical, there were also a few supportive voices, including one user who said that the chancellor isn’t to blame and that people should stand together instead of spreading hate. Several comments were posted by users with one or no visible friends on Facebook, suggesting that not all of them are genuine.

Beleaguered by a wave of anti-establishment sentiment in reaction to the refugee crisis, Merkel had appeared to weather the challenge, regaining some of the voter support lost to remain the favorite to win 2017 election. Yet she has remained vulnerable, with any potential terror attack among the factors cited as able to pollute the political climate.

Dark Day

The attack on a festive pre-Christmas crowd in the German capital came hours after Russia’s ambassador to Turkey was gunned down in Ankara and a shooting at an Islamic center in Zurich unleashed a manhunt. While Berlin’s experiences compounded the sense of unease across the region, it also served to underscore that it wasn’t alone.

“An attack can go one of two ways,” Holger Schmieding, chief economist at Berenberg Bank, said in a phone interview. “On the one hand it could lead in times of external dangers to people pulling together -- on the other it can also fan the extremists.”

Schmieding compared the probable assault to large-scale attacks in France since the beginning of 2015, in which more than 200 people were killed. In Nice on July 14, a truck plowed through a crowd on the city’s waterfront, killing 86.

Merkel’s image as a pillar of stability was tested in July when a spate of attacks, including a suicide bomber at a beer festival and an ax-wielding attacker on a commuter train -- both asylum seekers -- shook public opinion and renewed the debate on safety.

Ban Veils

Merkel in those cases vowed swift action against those who commit terrorism. Within her Christian Democratic Union, Merkel has toughened her stance on deportation of refugees who don’t qualify for asylum. At a party conference this month, she joined conservatives in calling for a ban on full-face veils where legally possible.

Looming on the party’s right flank is the AfD, which has swept into 10 state parliaments since its inception in 2013, including a string of electoral breakthroughs this year. The party’s rise has been accompanied by street rallies, particularly in the formerly communist east, that have featured slogans denouncing Islamist extremism.

“Your guess would have to be it’s yet another extremist Islam attack, that’s going to continue to weaken Merkel, that’s going to continue to support the populists,” Ian Bremmer, president of New York-based political risk consultancy Eurasia Group, said on Bloomberg TV.

For the chancellor, the daughter of a Lutheran pastor, Monday night’s deaths at a Berlin Christmas market are shocking, but the incident is not something that will catch her by surprise, according to Julianne Smith, senior fellow and director, Strategy and Statecraft Program at Center for a New American Security.

Merkel is “going to take hits on multiple sides," Smith said in an interview. “Some will accuse her of going too far and some will say she hasn’t done enough.”

— With assistance by Birgit Jennen, Nafeesa Syeed, Tony Czuczka, Nick Wadhams, and Stefan Nicola

    Before it's here, it's on the Bloomberg Terminal.
    LEARN MORE