Switzerland Risks Power Independence as Nuclear Vote Looms

  • Swiss faces hurdles distributing electricity within country
  • EU standoff excludes Swiss from single power market links

Switzerland risks becoming dependent on electricity imports as its citizens prepare for a plebiscite on whether to hasten its exit from nuclear power.

QuickTake Switzerland’s People Power

The nation faces losing a third of domestic supplies and becoming a net buyer of power if it opts to start closing its five nuclear plants as early as next year. The Swiss will vote on Sunday and the anti-nuclear proposal has a slender lead in opinion polls.

While Switzerland’s location is well suited to get power from its neighbors, its access to the European Union’s single market was hampered after the nation voted in 2014 to impose immigration quotas on EU citizens. As long as negotiations with EU on immigration drag on, direct access to the bloc’s electricity market remains out of bounds, weakening supply security.

“We would have to resort to electricity imports to fill up the loss of energy output,” said Nathalie Hardyn, deputy director at the Geneva Chamber of Commerce, who is against the initiative. “Right now we have an electricity network that cannot quickly increase imports for the long term.”

World’s Oldest

While Germany’s response to the Fukushima disaster in 2011 was to start decommissioning some of its reactors within months, the Swiss approach has been to phase out atomic generation by closing stations as they reach the end of their working lives, which could be almost 30 years from now. The country’s Beznau 1, opened in 1969, is the oldest operating reactor in the world.

Frustrated by the hazards in keeping the plants open for so long, the Green Party-led initiative calls for three reactors to close next year and the other two in 2024 and 2029. Supporters say the nation can easily make the transition to renewables as it already gets 60 percent of its electricity from hydropower plants. Nuclear provided about 34 percent of its power last year.

Tight Race

“Planning a phase out will make Parliament feel the heat under their feet and finance other projects,” said Philippe de Rougemont, a board member of the nuclear exit campaign. “The nuclear sector is a failing industry. It used to be the future and now it’s the past.”

Backing for the initiative is tight, with 48 percent in favor and 46 percent opposed, according to survey by gfs.bern for broadcaster SRG. Only four weeks earlier, a poll for the same company showed 57 percent supported an early exit, with 36 percent against.

The latest survey came before an earthquake rocked northern Japan off the coast of Fukushima on Tuesday. The quake, an aftershock of the one five years ago, briefly knocked offline a cooling system for spent nuclear fuel at a separate Fukushima plant.

Read more: Switzerland’s people power explained

An early nuclear exit would make it necessary to boost investments to accommodate increased imports as well as strengthen connections from hydropower plants to areas currently served by reactors, according to utilities BKW AG and Axpo Holding AG. That means higher energy bills for consumers.

“The risk of grid instabilities and ultimately blackouts would increase dramatically,” Tobias Kistner, an Axpo spokesman, said by e-mail. More time is needed for infrastructure investments, he said.

Quitting nuclear before plan would cost Axpo 4.1 billion francs ($4.1 billion) in lost revenue and decommissioning costs. Utility Alpiq Holding AG says it faces losing 2.5 billion francs. Both companies said they will seek compensation.

Switzerland’s net exports of electricity amounted to about 1 terawatt-hour last year, enough to power 200,000 European households. The country may need to bring in 5 terawatt-hours annually from 2018 and 20 terawatt-hours by 2029, according Markedskraft ASA.

The prospect of relying on imports comes when European electricity prices soared to records amid prolonged outages at reactors in France, a net power exporter to Switzerland last year. Germany’s plan to shut all of its nuclear plants by 2022 means it may have little room to be able to permanently export electricity to Switzerland.

“A hasty exit leads to more electricity imports and restricts the conversion of the energy supply system in Switzerland instead of developing it,” said Gilles Seuret, a BKW spokesman.

ReactorNet CapacityStartExp. Lifetime  Exp. ClosureExp. Closure in Plebiscite
Beznau 1365MW196960 years20292017
Beznau 2365MW197160 years20312017
Muehleberg373MW197247 years20192017
Goesgen1,010MW197960 years20392024
Leibstadt1,220MW198460 years20442029

Source: Axpo, BKW Energie, Alpiq

    Before it's here, it's on the Bloomberg Terminal.