San Francisco Landlords Gird for Slowdown as Startup Frenzy EbbsBy
Office-vacancy rate rises the most since the last recession
Pullback by startups, prospect of M&A fuel slowdown concern
Office landlords are bracing for a cooling of San Francisco’s red-hot market as weaker startup valuations and lower venture-capital funding temper years of runaway growth in the technology-industry hub.
The city’s office-vacancy rate jumped in the second quarter by the most since the last recession, while the amount of space available for sublease almost doubled, according to a report to be released this week by brokerage Cushman & Wakefield Inc. New lease deals have tumbled so far this year.
With demand seen cooling further, office owners who benefited from years of heated leasing by the likes of Uber Technologies Inc., Airbnb Inc. and Twitter Inc. are now rushing to seal deals and capture rents near record highs. They’re seeking to sign longer leases with creditworthy companies before prices slide, renewing agreements well ahead of their expiration and offering concessions, including free rent and cash for space improvements, according to J.D. Lumpkin, a managing director at Cushman & Wakefield in San Francisco.
“We may not be in a free fall, but it’s a sign of things to come,” Lumpkin said. “Those who are smart know it’s time to get aggressive and lock in credit tenants that you want for the next five, seven, 10 years in new leases and do whatever it takes.”
The moves represent a turn for a commercial real estate market that until recently had the nation’s lowest vacancy rate, driven by early stage tech firms scooping up space and Silicon Valley giants expanding to accommodate workers seeking an urban lifestyle. Now, the flood of money to startups is slowing and investors expect acquisitions of smaller companies whose valuations are falling, potentially leading to job cuts and office consolidation.
“There’s no question the market has cooled,” said David Dowdney, senior vice president of the western region at Atlanta-based Columbia Property Trust Inc., which owns three buildings in San Francisco. “Twelve months ago, you probably could have a very poor-looking space and it probably could lease anyway."
His company is becoming more flexible when negotiating leases, such as being open to letting workers bring their dogs to work and providing bike storage and access to gym and party space. About 25 percent of Columbia’s tenants are in the tech industry, including electronic-signature company DocuSign Inc.
“Tech startups were driving a lot of the activity a year ago,” Dowdney said. “There’s a lot more discipline.”
San Francisco’s office-vacancy rate rose to 7.3 percent in the second quarter from 5.7 percent in the previous three months, Cushman & Wakefield data show. It was the first increase since 2013, and the biggest since the start of 2009. The average asking rent, which can lag in a changing market, rose 1.3 percent to $69.30 a square foot.
New leasing declined 33 percent in the first half of 2016 from a year earlier. Available sublease space -- which can be an indicator of companies scaling back after growing too fast -- jumped to almost 1.5 million square feet (139,000 square meters) in the second quarter from 822,000 square feet in the prior three months.
“The market has turned and it’s not going to spike again,” Lumpkin said. “It’s going to flatten. Generally, landlords are speaking with tenants earlier in anticipation of a further market correction.”
Still, the city’s office-vacancy rate remains well below the national average of 13.5 percent, and its first-quarter rate of 5.7 percent was the lowest in the country. Many bigger, well-established companies are still clamoring for space.
“From what we’ve experienced in the last 30 to 60 days, there’s a new wave of activity from large San Francisco-based companies as well as Silicon Valley companies that are looking at the new developments and larger blocks of space,” said Chris Roeder, international director at Jones Lang LaSalle Inc. in San Francisco. “A lot of them are in expansion mode."
It’s mainly young startups that are becoming more conservative about their growth needs as venture-capital investors pay close attention to how their money is spent, Roeder said. Early stage investment tumbled 18 percent in the first quarter, according to PriceWaterhouseCoopers LLP and the National Venture Capital Association.
Startups that are expanding are benefiting from the cooling of the market.
Travana Inc., an online travel-agency startup, began operating in November with five employees and quickly outgrew its space at San Francisco’s Pier 5 as its workforce expanded to about 75. Jason Chen, the company’s chief executive officer, began looking for a bigger space in January and this month subleased the 40,000-square-foot top floor of 600 Townsend St. in San Francisco’s tech-heavy South of Market neighborhood, near Airbnb, Zynga Inc. and Pinterest Inc.
When he began negotiating a lease in April, the landlord offered him the half-built-out fourth floor, but later agreed to Chen’s request to lease the fully constructed fifth floor -- complete with a sundeck and furniture -- for the same price, he said.
“It seemed to get easier to negotiate the terms,” Chen said. “We are either very lucky or the market has turned.”
Microsoft Corp.’s $26.2 billion agreement to buy LinkedIn Corp. has prompted speculation that other tech companies may become acquisition targets. Increased merger and acquisitions activity may weigh on the real estate market as combined companies cut extra space, Cushman’s Lumpkin said.
“When M&A activity occurs, the fallout doesn’t tend to appear for a year because acquiring companies often times don’t exactly know what they want to do or how many duplicate resources are at the other companies,” said Tom McDonnell, senior vice president at landlord Shorenstein Realty Services LP.
The slowdown is happening in smaller increments of space and long-term demand remains robust, said McDonnell. Shorenstein’s six San Francisco office buildings house Twitter’s headquarters, Microsoft and Amazon.com Inc.
“It’s more of a leveling off that we’re seeing than any sort of decline,” McDonnell said. “That’s based upon a level of activity that was historic in San Francisco, so it’s all kind of relative.”