Can Takata Survive Its Historic U.S. Air Bag Recall?
Unlike industries in which companies have been quick to drop offending suppliers to protect their brands, automakers have largely stood behind air bag component maker Takata, taking the hit to their own reputations from a series of recalls related to the Japanese company’s products that began in 2008. One reason: The tight supply of air bag parts amid the post-recession rebound has left them little choice. Takata commands almost a quarter of the market for air bag inflators—a critical part in a modern vehicle.
That loyalty is about to be put to the test. On May 19, after months of pressure from U.S. regulators, Takata admitted its products are defective and launched a national recall of 34 million vehicles—the largest recall ever of any U.S. product. More important for carmakers, Takata’s rivals are finally ready to boost production of their own inflator products.
The 34 million cars in the U.S. that the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration says need air bags replaced tops the 31 million bottles of Tylenol that Johnson & Johnson recalled in 1982. And the number could grow larger due to a continuing investigation of other air bags, Takata spokesman Hideyuki Matsumoto says. In a statement, Chairman Shigehisa Takada said the company is on a clear path to “restoring the trust of automakers and the driving public.”
Others aren’t so sure, given the widespread reports that Takata’s inflators have ruptured during deployment, spewing shrapnel at car occupants, killing six and injuring more than 100. “It’s a complete nightmare,” says Jochen Siebert, managing director at JSC Automotive Consulting. “I just don’t see how Takata can survive this.”
Years of supplier consolidation encouraged by the big automakers has reduced parts supply to a handful of players. Takata and three rivals together control about 80 percent of the global air bag inflator market, estimates Valient Automotive Market Research.
Sweden’s Autoliv, which has 25 percent of the market, and Japan’s Daicel, with 16 percent, had been too stretched with capacity constraints to snag business from embattled Takata. But now both are within months of cranking up production. Autoliv says it will be able to make 25 million replacement inflators between now and the end of 2016; Daicel is ramping up a plant in Japan and will begin output in early 2016 at a factory it’s building in Arizona.
Even before it doubled the number of U.S. vehicles recalled, Takata was asking carmakers to let it use installments to pay for the cost of replacing defective bags. Chief Financial Officer Yoichiro Nomura told analysts in May that Takata was meeting bankers almost daily to ensure it has enough cash flow to weather the crisis. The company is also a major supplier of seat belts and steering wheel systems.
Takata may need to come up with about 300 billion yen ($2.5 billion) for the air bag recalls, says Yusuke Ueda, a credit analyst at Bank of America Merrill Lynch in Tokyo. That doesn’t include costs to resolve class-action suits concerning the defective parts, which began to be filed last year. The extent of that liability won’t be known for months. “It’s huge,” Ueda says of Takata’s future costs. “But if banks can provide additional loans and automakers are supportive, they can still survive this. The problem might be solved over time, because their cash flow from the other businesses is still stable.”
—With Jeff Plungis and Jeff Green
The bottom line: Takata expanded its recall of defective air bags to 34 million vehicles. Analysts say that could cost it $2.5 billion.