Yamana Poised to Prevail in Fight for OsiskoChristopher Donville
A week after Goldcorp Inc. Chairman Ian Telfer said he didn’t expect anyone to thwart his company’s C$2.73 billion ($2.47 billion) hostile offer for Osisko Mining Corp., Yamana Gold Inc. is poised to do just that.
Yamana’s C$1.47 billion offer for 50 percent of Osisko’s assets probably spells the demise of Goldcorp’s plan to buy the whole company, said Adam Graf, a New York-based analyst at Cowen & Co.
“The standing offer that they have should be the final offer, otherwise they risk a value-dilutive transaction,” Graf said of Goldcorp. “In our view, they should not up the ante.”
Yamana and Goldcorp are among producers looking to take advantage of a recent slump in gold prices to replenish their mine reserves and acquire more profitable operations. Osisko’s main asset is the Canadian Malartic project in Quebec, which Goldcorp has said would rank among the company’s top mines.
Telfer said March 25 that he didn’t expect anyone to top his company’s hostile bid for Osisko as rival producers remain deal-shy following writedowns on past takeovers.
Based on trading yesterday, investors now seem far less convinced Goldcorp will step up to beat its rival’s bid. Osisko climbed 7.3 percent to close at C$7.38 in Toronto. That was less than Yamana’s per-share offer valued at C$7.60 as of April 1, and compared with Goldcorp’s cash-and-stock bid, worth about C$6.29. Osisko fell to C$7.22 at the close today.
“The market is telling us this is a done deal,” Bart Jaworski, a Dublin-based resource analyst at Davy Research, said yesterday by phone.
Under the accord with Yamana, Osisko will keep its head office in Montreal, which may appease calls in Quebec for companies to remain based in the French-speaking province. Osisko investors will receive a combination of cash, Yamana stock and new common shares of Osisko. The companies said the deal’s aggregate value was about 10 percent more than Osisko’s closing price the previous day and 22 percent more than the value of the Goldcorp offer.
The Yamana deal also includes the participation of Canada’s two largest pension funds. Osisko agreed to sell a portion of its future gold from Canadian Malartic to Caisse de Depot et Placement du Quebec while the Canada Pension Plan Investment Board will increase an Osisko credit facility. Those agreements will provide Osisko with an additional C$550 million in funding, the company said yesterday.
The involvement of the pension funds may give Goldcorp reason to think twice about making another offer, said Robert Gill, who helps manage C$3.3 billion at Lincluden Investment Management, including Goldcorp shares.
“It might be difficult to have a deal like this actually come to fruition without some sort of involvement by them,” Gill said by phone.
Jeffrey Wilhoit, a Goldcorp spokesman, didn’t respond to calls seeking comment yesterday. Nick Anstett, a spokesman for Osisko who works for Longview Communications Inc., said Chief Executive Officer Sean Roosen wasn’t available to comment.
Canada Pension, the country’s largest manager of public pension funds, said it evaluated its transaction with Osisko “solely on its investment merits.”
The deal “offers CPPIB an attractive risk-adjusted return,” it said yesterday in a brief e-mailed statement.
The Caisse denied Osisko’s presence in Montreal was a consideration in its participation in the deal. The provincial government, which announced in February a proposal to protect Quebec companies from hostile takeovers, also wasn’t a factor in the deal, the fund said.
The Caisse, which is Osisko’s fourth-largest shareholder, invested in Osisko’s future gold production because it’s a sound transaction that meets its risk-return criteria, Maxime Chagnon, a spokesman, said yesterday by phone from Montreal.
For its part, the Quebec government said it supported the Yamana-Osisko deal because it would discourage other offers and keep Osisko based in Montreal, a goal shared with the Caisse.
“The involvement of the Caisse allows Osisko to preserve its future and gives it substantial means to resist other takeover offers that would deprive Quebec of an important head office,” Quebec Finance Minister Nicolas Marceau said yesterday at a press conference in Montreal amid the provincial election campaign. “The involvement of major institutional investors like the Caisse sends an important signal to the market.”
Goldcorp said today it had extended its formal bid for Osisko until April 15. The company was doing a full analysis of the Canadian Malartic mine and also was reviewing “the alternate scheme proposed between Osisko and a number of other parties,” according to a statement.
Not everyone believes Goldcorp, the world’s second-largest gold producer by market value, will give up its effort to acquire Osisko.
“We know they have the capacity to come back and potentially bid more,” Joseph Fazzini, a Toronto-based analyst at Dundee Capital Markets, said yesterday in a telephone interview. “They’ve said before that they would walk away, but frankly we still think that they would come back.”
Fazzini said the structure of the Yamana-Osisko plan, in which Osisko puts all of its current assets in general partnerships with Yamana, and other “messy” issues may turn off Osisko shareholders.
“The key thing here is they wouldn’t have to bid a whole lot more to get people on side,” Fazzini said of Goldcorp. “I think people would be willing to accept even just a slightly higher bid in exchange for a cleaner break -- no more messy deals or this weird stuff that is going on here.”
Michael Siperco, a Toronto-based analyst at Macquarie Capital Markets, said Goldcorp had good reason to consider a sweetened bid.
“If they don’t pull the trigger on a bump for Malartic, where else will they find production of 600,000 ounces a year in a very favorable mining jurisdiction?” Siperco said by phone.
Gill, the fund manager at Lincluden, said Yamana’s offer is closer to what Osisko is worth compared with Goldcorp’s Jan. 13 bid.
The 2 percent increase in Goldcorp’s stock price yesterday suggests “the market is really not concerned if they don’t raise their bid,” Gill said. “I’m a shareholder of Goldcorp. I don’t want to see them overpay.”