King Has Biggest Debut Drop Since November Even With DiscountLeslie Picker and Cliff Edwards
King Digital Entertainment Plc, maker of the “Candy Crush” smartphone game, suffered the biggest decline of a newly listed U.S. company in over four months even after it priced its shares at a discount to its major peers.
King’s shares dropped 16 percent to end trading at $19 today. King and shareholders Apax Partners LLP and Index Ventures raised $500 million in the IPO after pricing the stock at $22.50.
At the IPO price, King was valued at $7.09 billion, which made it cheaper -- relative to projected sales -- than publicly traded peers including Giant Interactive Group Inc. and Zynga Inc., data compiled by Bloomberg show. That had investors betting that they could profit from a quick jump in the shares once they began trading, said Jeffrey Sica of Sica Wealth Management LLC. Instead, concern that the popularity of “Candy Crush” will wane is weighing on the shares, he said.
“There were a lot of people hoping for momentum off the open and that didn’t happen,” said Sica, whose firm in Morristown, New Jersey, oversees more than $1 billion in assets. “If you don’t get momentum out of the gate you’re not going to get it, and it makes sense to cut your losses quickly rather than wait.”
The drop was the worst of any U.S. public offering since since textbook-renter Chegg Inc. slumped 23 percent in mid-November, data compiled by Bloomberg show. Of the 240 IPOs that have debuted over the last year, only about one quarter have closed down on their first day of trading, the data show. Chegg, which rents textbooks and provides digital homework help to college students, is down 43 percent since its IPO.
King shares were offered at a multiple of 2.7 times projected sales of $2.62 billion, based on an estimate from Arvind Bhatia, an analyst at Sterne Agee & Leach Inc. Giant Interactive traded at 6.3 times estimated 2014 sales, and Zynga fetched 5.2 times as of yesterday’s market close. Activision Blizzard Inc., the largest U.S. video-game publisher, traded at
3.2 times estimated 2014 sales.
“Candy Crush,” a puzzle game featuring different-colored candies, has 97 million daily active users, the IPO prospectus shows. It accounts for 78 percent of King’s sales, which King generates when users purchase virtual items, such as extra lives or additional content, for about $1 apiece. Its other games, including “Farm Heroes Saga” and “Bubble Witch Saga,” each have fewer than 20 million daily users.
King’s discount may reflect lessons investors learned following Zynga’s debut. The maker of “FarmVille” went public in December 2011, dropped 5 percent in its first day of trading and slumped almost 80 percent in the subsequent year. Zynga’s revenue, like King’s, was concentrated in one major source at the time of its IPO: more than 90 percent of its sales came from Facebook Inc. Shares continued to slide as Zynga’s users started defecting to “Candy Crush.”
There’s revenue potential for King in growing its lesser-known games, according to Chief Executive Officer Riccardo Zacconi.
“Our strategy is not focused on finding another ‘Candy Crush’ -- ‘Candy Crush’ has been an incredible success,” Zacconi said in a Bloomberg TV interview from the New York Stock Exchange. “The target is to build a portfolio of high-quality games.”
Unlike Zynga, which hasn’t posted an annual profit since it went public, King’s after-tax profit margin was 30 percent last year, its prospectus shows.
Apax, which planned to sell about 2 percent of its shares in the IPO, invested 28.9 million euros in King in 2005, then worth $35 million. The IPO price values its pre-offering stake at $3.25 billion. In addition, the firm has received $266 million in dividends.
U.S.-based investors in Apax, a majority of the firm’s backers, will score about a 100-fold partly realized gross profit in the offering. The firm’s euro-based investors will post about an 87-fold gain.
Index Ventures, a Geneva-based venture-capital shop that invested 5 million euros alongside Apax, will reap a return of similar magnitude.
King’s shares are listed on the New York Stock Exchange under the symbol KING. JPMorgan Chase & Co., Credit Suisse Group AG and Bank of America Corp. managed the offering.