Markets

Mark Gilbert is a Bloomberg Gadfly columnist covering asset management. He previously was a Bloomberg View columnist, and prior to that the London bureau chief for Bloomberg News. He is the author of “Complicit: How Greed and Collusion Made the Credit Crisis Unstoppable.”

South Africa's downgrade on Monday after the nation's finance minister was fired means three of the five BRICS nations now have junk credit assessments at S&P Global Ratings.

For dollar-based investors betting on the group's stocks and bonds, the history of this decade suggests that matters less -- much less -- than hedging the currency risk accompanying those investments.

Jim O'Neill, the then chairman of Goldman Sachs Asset Management, coined the term in his 2001 research note "Building Better Global Economic BRICs." O'Neill argued that the emerging market nations were under-represented in the various supranational forums, given their likely future contributions to global gross domestic product. Leaders of Brazil, Russia, India and China held their first formal summit in 2009; South Africa officially joined the gang a year later.

In terms of growth, Brazil has suffered the biggest decline as the economy slumped into a recession in 2014 and stayed there. All except India have seen gross domestic product deteriorate this decade.

Slowing Down
Annual change in GDP
Source: Bloomberg
Note: India's data series begins in Q2 2012

That recession has dragged down the performance of Brazilian stocks, although it's the Chinese equity market, as measured by the Hang Seng China Enterprises Index that trades in Hong Kong, that's the laggard, losing almost 20 percent. The benchmark South African index is the clear winner among the BRICS this decade. Its gains contrast with the benchmark MSCI Emerging Markets Index's decline of about 4 percent since the start of 2010.

South Africa Leads BRICS Equities
Benchmark stock index performance this decade
Source: Bloomberg

Benchmark bonds haven't really moved much since the start of the decade. South Africa's cost of borrowing for 10 years jumped after President Jacob Zuma fired finance minister Pravin Gordhan last week. S&P blamed "political uncertainty" for its decision to downgrade the country. The move, though, leaves the 10-year yield at about 9 percent -- in line with where it was at the start of 2010. Yields for the rest of the BRICS are similarly becalmed:

BRICS Bonds Becalmed
Benchmark 10-year local currency yields
Source: Bloomberg

It's the currency market, though, that's seen the most action. China's currency started the decade trading at about 6.83 to the dollar, strengthened to about 6 by the start of 2014, but has since retreated all the way back to be little changed. The other four currencies, however, have depreciated substantially.

All Fall Down (Apart From China)
Performance of BRICS currencies against the dollar this decade
Source: Bloomberg

To be sure, the above chart says more about dollar strength than it does about emerging-market currency weakness. This decade, the dollar has made ground against almost every currency in the world (with the notable exceptions of the Somali shilling, the Guatemalan Quetzal and the Icelandic krona).

The BRICS moniker was a useful tool in focusing the investment community on the likely winners among emerging markets; more than 480 investment funds in various flavors, currencies and domiciles use the term in their titles, according to data compiled by Bloomberg.

In January 2014, O'Neill shifted his attention to the so-called MINT countries -- Mexico, Indonesia, Nigeria and Turkey. The history of the BRICS this decade suggests investors looking to make money from that selection need to have the currency angle front and center of their thinking.

This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of Bloomberg LP and its owners.

To contact the author of this story:
Mark Gilbert in London at magilbert@bloomberg.net

To contact the editor responsible for this story:
Edward Evans at eevans3@bloomberg.net