Skip to content
Bloomberg the Company & Its ProductsThe Company & its ProductsBloomberg Terminal Demo RequestBloomberg Anywhere Remote LoginBloomberg Anywhere LoginBloomberg Customer SupportCustomer Support
  • Bloomberg

    Connecting decision makers to a dynamic network of information, people and ideas, Bloomberg quickly and accurately delivers business and financial information, news and insight around the world

    For Customers

    • Bloomberg Anywhere Remote Login
    • Software Updates
    • Manage Products and Account Information

    Support

    Americas+1 212 318 2000

    EMEA+44 20 7330 7500

    Asia Pacific+65 6212 1000

  • Company

    • About
    • Careers
    • Diversity and Inclusion
    • Tech At Bloomberg
    • Philanthropy
    • Sustainability
    • Bloomberg London
    • Bloomberg Beta
    • Gender-Equality Index

    Communications

    • Press Announcements
    • Press Contacts

    Follow

    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • LinkedIn
    • Instagram
  • Products

    • Bloomberg Terminal
    • Execution and Order Management
    • Content and Data
    • Financial Data Management
    • Integration and Distribution
    • Bloomberg Tradebook

    Industry Products

    • Bloomberg Law
    • Bloomberg Tax
    • Bloomberg Government
    • BloombergNEF
  • Media

    • Bloomberg Markets
    • Bloomberg Technology
    • Bloomberg Pursuits
    • Bloomberg Politics
    • Bloomberg Opinion
    • Bloomberg Businessweek
    • Bloomberg Live Conferences
    • Bloomberg Apps
    • Bloomberg Radio
    • Bloomberg Television
    • News Bureaus

    Media Services

    • Bloomberg Media Distribution
    • Advertising
  • Company

    • About
    • Careers
    • Diversity and Inclusion
    • Tech At Bloomberg
    • Philanthropy
    • Sustainability
    • Bloomberg London
    • Bloomberg Beta
    • Gender-Equality Index

    Communications

    • Press Announcements
    • Press Contacts

    Follow

    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • LinkedIn
    • Instagram
  • Products

    • Bloomberg Terminal
    • Execution and
      Order Management
    • Content and Data
    • Financial Data
      Management
    • Integration and
      Distribution
    • Bloomberg
      Tradebook

    Industry Products

    • Bloomberg Law
    • Bloomberg Tax
    • Bloomberg Government
    • Bloomberg Environment
    • BloombergNEF
  • Media

    • Bloomberg Markets
    • Bloomberg
      Technology
    • Bloomberg Pursuits
    • Bloomberg Politics
    • Bloomberg Opinion
    • Bloomberg
      Businessweek
    • Bloomberg Live Conferences
    • Bloomberg Apps
    • Bloomberg Radio
    • Bloomberg Television
    • News Bureaus

    Media Services

    • Bloomberg Media Distribution
    • Advertising
  • Bloomberg

    Connecting decision makers to a dynamic network of information, people and ideas, Bloomberg quickly and accurately delivers business and financial information, news and insight around the world

    For Customers

    • Bloomberg Anywhere Remote Login
    • Software Updates
    • Manage Contracts and Orders

    Support

    Americas+1 212 318 2000

    EMEA+44 20 7330 7500

    Asia Pacific+65 6212 1000

Bloomberg UK

Switch Editions
  • UK
  • Europe
  • US
  • Asia
  • Middle East
  • Africa
  • 日本
Sign In Subscribe
  • Bloomberg TV+

    Bloomberg Daybreak Middle East

    Bloomberg Daybreak Middle East

    Bloomberg Daybreak Middle East. Live from Dubai, connecting Asian markets to the European opens. The show will focus on global macro issues with a middle eastern context, provide expert analysis of major market moving stories and speak with the biggest newsmakers in the region.

    Bloomberg Radio

    BTV Simulcast

    BTV Simulcast

    Simulcast of Bloomberg Television

    Listen

    Quicktake

    I Love Wine - Arajon

    I Love Wine - Arajon

    I Love Wine transports you to the best winemaking regions of the world, where the people behind the grapes explain how the culture and the landscape have shaped their product.

    Also streaming on your TV:

    • Markets
      Markets
      • Economics
      • Deals
      • Odd Lots
      • The FIX | Fixed Income
      • ETFs
      • FX
      • Factor Investing
      • Alternative Investing
      • Economic Calendar
      • Markets Magazine
      Central Business District As Goldman, HSBC to Open Hong Kong Offices Fully

      Markets

      Asia’s SPAC Hopefuls Have Nowhere to Turn As IPO Market Shuts

      SPAIN-ECONOMY-BANKING-DIPLOMACY

      New Economy

      Latin America Has Opportunity ‘to Shine,’ IDB’s President Says

      Market Data

      • Stocks
      • Commodities
      • Rates & Bonds
      • Currencies
      • Futures
      • Sectors

      Follow Bloomberg Markets

      View More Markets
    • Technology
      Technology
      • Work Shifting
      • Code Wars
      • Checkout
      • Prognosis
      Cerebral CEO Fights for His Job Amid US Prescription Probe

      Technology

      Cerebral CEO Fights for His Job Amid US Prescription Probe

      Twitter Headquarters As Musk Secures Financing For Potential Takeover

      Technology

      As Musk Tweets, Advisers Plug Away to Keep Twitter Deal on Track

      Singapore’s Jungle Ventures Raises $600 Million to Back Startups

      Technology

      Singapore’s Jungle Ventures Raises $600 Million to Back Startups

      Follow Bloomberg Technology

      View More Technology
    • Politics
      Politics
      • US
      • UK
      • Americas
      • Europe
      • Asia
      • Middle East
      Former President Trump Holds Rally In North Carolina

      Politics

      Trump Backing Fails to Help Madison Cawthorn Keep US House Seat

      Independent For Goldstein Zoe Daniel Greets Early Voters At Polling Centre Ahead Of Federal Election

      Politics

      Australia Prime Minister Race Tightens Ahead of Weekend Election

      Featured

      • Next China

      Follow Bloomberg Politics

      View More Politics
    • Wealth
      Wealth
      • Investing
      • Living
      • Opinion & Advice
      • Savings & Retirement
      • Taxes
      • Reinvention
      Mike Krzyzewski

      Investing

      Duke’s Coach K Was Paid Nearly $14 Million in 2020

      Walmart Stores Ahead Of Earnings Figures

      Wealth

      World’s Richest Family Loses $19 Billion in Walmart Wipeout

      Featured

      • How to Invest

      Follow Bloomberg Wealth

      View More Wealth
    • Pursuits
      Pursuits
      • Travel
      • Autos
      • Homes
      • Living
      • Culture
      • Style
      Magic Moment: Orlando Wins Lottery, Lands No. 1 Pick

      Pursuits

      Magic Moment: Orlando Wins Lottery, Lands No. 1 Pick

      Department Store Century 21 Files Bankruptcy, Will Shut Down

      Checkout

      Century 21 Store Returns to NYC After Pandemic Closure and Bankruptcy

      Featured

      • Screentime
      • New York Property Prices
      • Where to Go in 2022

      Follow Bloomberg Pursuits

      View More Pursuits
    • Opinion
      Opinion
      • Business
      • Finance
      • Economics
      • Markets
      • Politics & Policy
      • Technology & Ideas
      • Editorials
      • Letters
      GERMANY-HEALTH-VIRUS

      John Authers

      History Says Buying the Dips Is a Dangerous Game

      CHINA-ECONOMY

      Anjani Trivedi

      Can a Covid-Zero China Still Lift Up the World?

      Wheat Harvest As India Experiences Heat Wave

      David Fickling

      The Global Safety Net Against Hunger Is Frailer Than You Think

      Follow Bloomberg Opinion

      View More Opinion
    • Businessweek
      Businessweek
      • The Bloomberg 50
      • Best B-Schools
      • Small Business Survival Guide
      • 50 Companies to Watch
      • Good Business
      • Subscribe to the Magazine
      Tech’s High-Flying Startup Scene Gets a Crushing Reality Check

      The Big Take

      Tech’s High-Flying Startup Scene Gets a Crushing Reality Check

      China’s Pullback on Lending Stalls Dreams of Rebuilding Nigeria

      Economics

      China’s Pullback on Lending Stalls Dreams of Rebuilding Nigeria

      The Tighter Labor Market Is Making Restaurants More Like Factories

      Remarks

      The Tighter Labor Market Is Making Restaurants More Like Factories

      Follow Bloomberg Businessweek

      View More Businessweek
    • Equality
      Equality
      • Corporate Leadership
      • Capital
      • Society
      • Solutions
      Pacific Investment Management Company LLC Advertisement

      Equality

      Pimco Sued Over ‘Fraternity’ Culture by Minority Ex-Workers

      SPAIN-POLITICS-PODEMOS

      Equality

      Plan to Grant Paid Leave for Period Pain Stirs Tensions in Spain

      TOPSHOT-BELGIUM-HUN-POLITICS-LGBT-RIGHTS-EU

      Equality

      Belgium Aims to Combat Anti-LGBTQ Assaults With New Action Plan

      Follow Bloomberg Equality

      View More Equality
    • Green
      Green
      • Science & Energy
      • Climate Adaptation
      • Finance
      • Politics
      • Culture & Design
      The $300 Billion Plan to Bring Clean Power to China's Megacities

      Green

      China Is Ready to Make Electricity Out of (Not So) Thin Air

      The Furnas Hydroelectric Dam As Brazil's Congress Allows Eletrobras Privatization

      Green

      Tropical Cyclone Blacks Out 182,000 Homes in Southern Brazil

      Featured

      • Data Dash
      • Hyperdrive

      Follow Bloomberg Green

      View More Green
    • CityLab
      CityLab
      • Design
      • Culture
      • Transportation
      • Economy
      • Environment
      • Housing
      • Justice
      • Government
      • Technology
      Time zones abstract concept vector illustration.

      Design

      Architects Draft a New Blueprint for a Labor Movement

      Police protest Corky Lee

      Culture

      A Photographer’s Mission to Write Asian Americans Back Into History

      Lincoln Covered Bridge Is Repaired

      Government

      Here’s How to Get Infrastructure Funds to Smaller Cities

      Follow Bloomberg CityLab

      View More CityLab
    • Crypto
      Crypto
      • Decentralized Finance
      • NFTs
      • Regulation
      • Technology
      DAI coin

      Crypto

      DAI Is King Of Decentralized Stablecoins After Terra Collapse

      Bank Of England Sees Fallout on House Prices, Pound From No-Deal Brexit

      Crypto

      Crypto Assets Poorly Understood by Retail Investors, BOE Says

      Inside Bitmain Technologies Ltd.'s Bitcoin Mine

      Crypto

      China Makes a Comeback in Bitcoin Mining Despite Government Ban

      Follow Bloomberg Crypto

      View More Crypto

Live on Bloomberg TV

CC-Transcript

  • 00:00From a legal basis in your view how would you describe the essence in the case against Facebook. Well the essence is that Facebook did not acquire and grow and maintain its monopoly power by competing based on merit to outperform competitors. Instead it pursued a buy or burry strategy buying competitive threats. And for those companies that couldn't buy it would bury them with anti-competitive conduct. Now a lot of people seem to think this is just the way business is done. Perhaps that's because our antitrust laws have been very weakly enforced particularly in the tech sector. But the Clayton Act does prohibit mergers that may tend to lessen competition or create a monopoly. And the Sherman Act prohibits illegal monopolization. So the state ages sue Facebook for both of those claims and the FTC sues Facebook just for the Sherman Act violation. So Sally I mean the general assumption is that yes this is how a lot of companies act particularly in the tech space and particularly with social media and the networking effect. And there's almost an expectation of it of that for these companies act that way by investors if there is not sort of a mechanism and enforcement mechanism in the government to clamp down on this what really is stopping them because it's not really clear that there is anything there are they can stop them. Oh enforcers could definitely be stopping these illegal mergers. You know FTSE did. Look at the WhatsApp Instagram mergers. It should have taken a closer look at the time but the Clayton Act does not have any kind of a time limit. And often when an enforcer is looking at a merger what they're doing is really making guesses about the future. They may not have the evidence at that time but they have the evidence now. I'm curious though Sally when we talk about the reviews though I mean one Facebook defense that they put out there at least was the idea that these mergers were vetted before. So if the Clinton check if there wasn't anything there for it to be applied at the time why would there be something there to apply in the future. You know I think these mergers were legal at the time and the FTC didn't see the evidence didn't have enough evidence at that time. From his view to block the deals. But the evidence is now abundantly clear that they were illegal. They did tend to create a monopoly. They did substantially lessen competition. But the other important thing to remember is that the Sherman Act prohibits illegal monopolization. And what the states and the FTC are arguing is that there was a pattern of these anti-competitive acquisitions combined with anti-competitive uses of data denying any company that dared compete against Facebook access to the Friends API. That was a legal monopolization over the course of several years. So it's not just looking at the independent mergers but rather a pattern of monopolization. The Shery Ahn reaction has been pretty muted. Many knew this was coming of course but there's a feeling that they just won't be broken up. That's just too difficult to exert. And certainly when you talk to Margaret best year over in Europe she's not saying break up these companies and she's been hounding them for a lot longer than the US has a monopolistic grounds and instead exerting fines. What do you think are the more likely business model changes that could be forced upon them. I actually think a breakup is likely thanks to European enforcement efforts that have largely failed. It's become very clear to the world that these behavioral modifications just don't work. I mean kudos to Vestager for bringing those cases against Google but none of her remedies have worked. Everyone who's been involved says they're a complete failure because they were behavioral remedies. And fortunately these tech companies are too hard to modify and a behavioral way because they have way too many levers to push to distort competition. What's really needed is a structural reform. So I actually do think structural reform is what we're going to ultimately see in these cases. What do you mean by that. Structural reform. Is it like beyond just these sort of agglomeration of different businesses that is problematic or something about how our big tech giants or Facebook in particular in this case does business. Whether Instagram is part of it or not. Right well so most of the tech giants have a problem where they're both controlling the platform and competing on the platform. And so the argument for structural separation is separating out the Congress from the platform itself. With Facebook it's a little hard to understand how it does that but it does do a preferential practice of giving you know as algorithms incentivize and prioritize particular types of content. The content that makes Facebook the most money is the content that makes people click and share. So there is an issue there with picking winners and losers of content. So part of it is always about removing the incentive and ability to favor particular types of businesses or your own self over others. What's Facebook. What we really need is some competitive constraint on Facebook. You know if you look at the camera analytics scandal that angered so many people they deleted Facebook and they chose to use Instagram most night and realizing that Facebook had bought Instagram which was its number one substitute. So what we really need our independent competitors out there so consumers can have choice and we can have better innovations of how to do social networking in a way that's less harmful.
  • NOW PLAYING

    Facebook Pursued a ‘Buy or Bury’ Strategy With Its Monopoly Power: Sally Hubbard

  • 04:53

    17Sigma Managing Partner on Latin America's Startups

  • 01:52:09

    Bloomberg Markets: The Close (5/17/2022)

  • 04:46

    Pro Mujer on Microfinancing Women in Latin America

  • 06:05

    Inter-American Development Bank on Latin America's Challenges, Potential

  • 04:39

    CFR's O'Neil on Latin America Outlook

  • 04:34

    Arena Investors' Zwirn on Markets and Strategies

  • 04:04

    Cope Corrales' Sissel on Market Outlook

  • 08:35

    Animoca Brands Co-Founder Siu on Crypto, NFTs, Web3

  • 47:04

    'Bloomberg Daybreak: Australia' Full Show (05/18/2022)

  • 03:07

    Shanghai Slowly Emerges From Lockdown; Beijing Covid Cases Rise

  • 52:26

    Balance of Power Full Show (05/17/2022)

  • 01:08

    Zelenskiy: Ukraine Working on Azovstal Evacuation

  • 05:38

    BNP Paribas Is 'Overweight' South Korea, Indonesia, India, Hong Kong

  • 44:49

    'Bloomberg Technology' Full Show (05/17/2022)

  • 06:00

    Bessemer Venture's Bennett on Software Firms, Startups

Stream Schedule:

U.S. BTV+
  • U.S. BTV+
  • U.S. BTV
  • Europe BTV
  • Asia BTV
  • Australia BTV
  • U.S. Live Event
  • EMEA Live Event
  • Asia Live Event
  • Politics Live Event
No schedule data available.

Facebook Pursued a ‘Buy or Bury’ Strategy With Its Monopoly Power: Sally Hubbard

  • What'd You Miss?

  • TV Shows

December 10th, 2020, 11:40 PM GMT+0000

The U.S. Federal Trade Commission took a major step toward the possible breakup of Facebook by formally filing an antitrust lawsuit against the technology giant, accusing it of abusing its monopoly powers in social networking to stifle competition. Sally Hubbard, director of enforcement policy at the Open Markets Institute and author of “Monopolies Suck", speaks with Bloomberg's Caroline Hyde, Romaine Bostick and Joe Weisenthal on "What'd You Miss?" about Facebook. (Source: Bloomberg)


  • More From What'd You Miss?

    • 03:45

      Apple Sales Top Estimates, New Buybacks Announced

    • 05:38

      China's Lockdown Hurts Global Tourism, Says Harteveldt

    • 03:09

      Amazon to Split Stock 20-1, Plans $10 Billion Buyback

    • 21:05

      Bloomberg Markets: What'd You Miss? (03/04/2022)

    All episodes and clips
  • Bloomberg Markets

    "Bloomberg Markets" is focused on bringing you the most important global business and breaking markets news and information as it happens.
    More episodes and clips
    • 52:26

      Balance of Power Full Show (05/17/2022)

    • 44:49

      'Bloomberg Technology' Full Show (05/17/2022)

    • 05:10

      Alberta Says It Can Boost Oil Output by 900,000 Barrels Per Day

    • 19:21

      Bloomberg Markets Full Show (05/17/2022)

  • QuickTake

    Explaining the world with Bloomberg News
    More episodes and clips
    • 01:42

      Ikea to Start Selling Renewable Energy to Homes in Sweden

    • 02:17

      Power of TikTok Shown to Boost Sales

    • 03:03

      Grocery-Store Boom to Outlive Pandemic?

    • 02:45

      Inside the History of Montreal’s Plex Homes

See all shows
Terms of Service Trademarks Privacy Policy ©2022 Bloomberg L.P. All Rights Reserved
Careers Made in NYC Advertise Ad Choices Help