Will Paul Ryan Follow James Polk's Playbook?

If the Wisconsin Republican wants to be president, becoming speaker is an odd choice.

Forward thinker.

Photographer: Matthew Brady/Getty Images

Republican presidential aspirants often hold up Ronald Reagan as a model. For Democrats, it's Franklin D. Roosevelt or John F. Kennedy. No one cites James K. Polk.

That may change if Representative Paul Ryan of Wisconsin becomes speaker of the House. Most Republicans assume that the 45-year-old lawmaker, who was Mitt Romney's running mate in 2012, will seek the presidency someday. Only one House speaker has been elected president: Polk, in 1844.

QuickTake Speaker of the House

Becoming speaker would shape any future presidential prospects for Ryan, who announced Tuesday evening that he would be willing to seek the job if Republicans made a commitment to unify behind him. "This is not a job I’ve ever wanted," he said, adding that he wanted an answer from fellow Republicans by the end of the week. 

Former Republican Representative Vin Weber, a close colleague of Ryan's, said that despite the singular record of speakers who became president, taking the post would "enhance" Ryan's White House prospects: "How many presidents have been elected from the Ways and Means Committee?" 

As speaker, Ryan would be the dominant figure in the party. If he is able to forge and maintain a semblance of unity in the unruly House Republican Caucus, it would be a real achievement. 

Yet if he is forced to tilt further right to achieve that goal, it might pose more problems for any subsequent national run.

And if a Speaker Ryan ended up suffering the same fate as John Boehner -- simply unable to manage the disparate party elements in the House -- the job might even be a disqualifier for future ambitions.

Much, however, would depend on which party occupies the White House after 2016. If a Speaker Ryan is credited with securing passage of a Republican president's agenda, and helping to shape it, it would be a strong calling card, say in 2024 when Ryan will be 54, the same age as President Barack Obama today.

But if a Democrat is elected next year and Ryan still is speaker, it may be, to cite Yogi Berra, deja vu all over again.

Polk, who many historians rate as a near great president though he only served one term, was speaker for four years, the first two when his mentor, Andrew Jackson, was president. By contrast, his later tenure as governor of Tennessee was a failure. He lost his re-election as well as a later bid. He recouped somehow to win the presidency in 1844.

"His only real political success before the presidency was as speaker," said Robert W. Merry, author of "A Country of Vast Designs," an acclaimed biography of Polk. "He had his detractors but he never shied from controversy."

This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the editorial board or Bloomberg LP and its owners.

    To contact the author of this story:
    Albert R. Hunt at

    To contact the editor responsible for this story:
    Max Berley at

    Before it's here, it's on the Bloomberg Terminal.