2016 Elections

Scott Walker Gets Winnowed

We may be very close to having a Republican nominee.

Where's the party?

Photographer: Steve Pope/Getty Images

Everyone is busy analyzing what did in Scott Walker, who suspended his campaign for the Republican presidential nomination on Monday night.  

I’ll hold off on jumping into that discussion, and focus instead on the important news about the nomination process: Winnowing works, even in the era of super-PACs. The harsh logic of the system pushes losing candidates out of the race, until only a winner remains.

Remember: We began this last year with about 22 politicians doing the things politicians do if they’re running for president.

Five in that group -- Mitt Romney, Mike Pence, Rob Portman, Bob Ehrlich and John Bolton -- dropped out before formally announcing their candidacies.

Two more -- Rick Perry and now Walker -- made it to the announcement and debate stage, but not as far as the Iowa caucuses.

Of the remaining 15 contenders, fewer than half -- Jeb Bush, Marco Rubio, John Kasich, Mike Huckabee, Bobby Jindal, Chris Christie and Rick Santorum -- have conventional qualifications for the job and are within the party mainstream on questions of public policy. The chances are very good that one of them will wind up on the stage in Cleveland next year as the nominee. And of those seven, only Bush, Rubio and maybe Kasich are showing any forward momentum at all. Nonetheless, candidates have rebounded from seeming to be done for to becoming a serious challenge for their party's nomination.

As David Karol pointed out at the Monkey Cage, this has been the pattern in recent Republican contests. The losers drop out early. It isn't entirely clear why this happens more on the Republican side than among Democrats (for example, Martin O’Malley is chugging along with no apparent support). It's possible something is happening below the surface. Maybe Republican party actors are coordinating to gently (or maybe not so gently) apply pressure on losing candidates to exit at this point.

Plausible candidates are probably more likely to drop out than those such as Ben Carson or Donald Trump. Tim Pawlenty, the former governor of Minnesota, exited early in 2012, but Michele Bachmann and Newt Gingrich hung on longer in that cycle, and so might several implausible nominees this time around.

The bottom line is we may be getting close to having a Republican presidential nominee. It’s probably down to just two or three candidates. And it wouldn’t be surprising if one or more of the plausible nominees joined Walker and Perry on the bench before Christmas.

This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the editorial board or Bloomberg LP and its owners.