Give China's Devaluation a Chance
China's surprise devaluation is sure to stir up fear and loathing among the world's economic populists. (Keep your eyes on Donald Trump's Twitter account.) But the move deserves praise, not condemnation. It might even prove a boon for world growth.
Beijing spent much of the last year propping up the yuan to combat capital outflows, avoid debt defaults and win a place among the International Monetary Fund's five reserve currencies. But with growth sputtering and deflation looming, China has now reversed course, cutting its daily reference rate yesterday by 1.9 percent, the most in two decades. The Chinese government has effectively admitted that risks are accelerating in the world's second-biggest economy.
Politicians in the U.S. are sure to call the devaluation a threat to American jobs, and politicians in Japan will bemoan its effects on their deflation fight. But it's important to keep a sense of perspective. China has called this a one-time fix designed to push the yuan toward a more market-determined system, in accordance with the IMF's wishes. Besides, if China were going all-in on a beggar-thy-neighbor policy, its devaluation would have been far more substantial -- and even then, there's no guarantee it would have succeeded at propping up the economy. The yen's 35 percent plunge since late 2012 is hardly reviving Japan, any more than this year's 10 percent currency drop is saving Australia. (And let's be honest about the hypocrisy at work: nobody gave Tokyo or Canberra grief for their dramatic currency drops.)
It's also important to acknowledge that Beijing's new policy poses risks for China. The weaker yuan increases the odds of a surge in defaults on foreign-currency debt, which makes the country highly vulnerable to capital flight. In April, Shenzhen-based Kaisa became the first Chinese developer to renege on such debts. The People's Bank of China is aware a lower yuan could push others to the brink, which is why it probably won't allow the currency to fall too much farther.
The real question isn't whether Beijing should have devalued the yuan, but what it does with the time this maneuver buys. Given how little tolerance President Xi Jinping and Premier Li Keqiang have shown for the shock therapy China needs to wean itself off excessive investment and exports, it would be reasonable to assume the currency move is a tactic to delay reforms and re-inflate the country's stock bubble. If the government unveils new policies to prop up stocks -- thus giving the impression the devaluation was essentially a stock market intervention -- then it could reignite the global currency war.
But there's a more optimistic view: Beijing might be buying some stability so it can accelerate the reform process. From that perspective, this week's news that China is preparing to tackle its state-owned-enterprise problem looks even more promising. According to the South China Morning Post, China is creating two new kinds of companies to supervise and regulate state-owned behemoths. The scheme is modeled after Singapore's state-owned investment arm Temasek and, if handled well, it has the potential to alter the foundations of Asia's biggest economy for the better.
These politically-coddled monopolies are at the nexus of all of Beijing's worst excesses -- debt, overcapacity, corruption, pollution. Reducing their influence would be a vital first step for cultivating the sort of startup boom that China needs.
But it won't be easy. Kickbacks from land grabs, insider trading and old-school rent seeking have minted countless millionaires among Xi's Community Party comrades. These vested interests will battle Xi's every effort to make SOEs more open, competitive and conventionally profitable.
Taking on this fight would be easier for Xi if China's exports weren't falling (they dropped by 8.3 percent in July) and deflation didn't loom as a threat. That's where Tuesday's devaluation, and the expected boost to exports, come in. It's plausible that SOE reform motivated the Chinese government's devaluation decision.
If Xi is truly interested in allowing the market to play a leading role in economic decision making, the real test will be whether his government shows the courage to open the country's opaque financial system, tighten corporate governance and allow the media to play a bigger role in weeding out corruption. Rather than bellyaching about the latest currency move, these are the steps China critics should be watching for. Personally, I can't help but feel optimistic that China's yuan-regime change suggests they're coming.
This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the editorial board or Bloomberg LP and its owners.
To continue reading this article you must be a Bloomberg Professional Service Subscriber.
If you believe that you may have received this message in error please let us know.
- How Long Can Trump's Long Con Last?
- Trump on Your Resume? Uh-Oh
- What History Says About Trump's Re-Election Prospects
- How to Avoid a Retirement Disaster
- The Ugly Coded Critique of Chick-Fil-A's Christianity
- Holding Up a Mirror to the Intellectuals of the Left
- Trump's Promising Plan to Link Welfare to Work