The Estate Tax
U.S. Rich Follow Rockefeller’s Lead in Hunt for Loopholes
One of the first Americans to beat the estate tax was a guy by the name of John D. Rockefeller. Not long after Congress in 1916 declared a special new tax on the estates of people who died with more than $50,000, the oil tycoon, then the world’s richest man, gave hundreds of millions of dollars to his son. It took eight years for Congress to plug the gap. The episode was the first round in what’s become a century-long cat-and-mouse game. The cats are Congressional lawmakers, and the nation’s wealthy are the mice. A whole industry, known as estate planning, sprang up to counsel taxpayers on how to play the game. The mice are winning. There are so many legal shelters that for many of the wealthiest Americans the estate tax has become all but voluntary. Now the presidential race is giving Americans a choice: abolish the tax or make it tougher?
The U.S. estate tax rate is 40 percent. It currently applies only to the portions of estates above $5.45 million, or $10.9 million for couples. Those levels were set as part of a 2010 deal between President Barack Obama and Congressional Republicans that eased the tax. Hillary Clinton, the Democratic presidential nominee, has called for rolling the rules back to where they stood before the deal, with thresholds of $3.5 million for individuals or $7 million for married couples, and a 45 percent rate. Donald Trump, the Republican nominee, wants to repeal the tax altogether. Because of the loopholes and the large exemption, the estate and gift taxes together raised just $20 billion in 2014, less than 1 percent of federal tax revenue, down from $31 billion as recently as 2008. Fewer than one in 600 people who die in 2015 will have to pay any estate tax. Even so, the tax remains unpopular with the American public. Just as the U.S. seems to lack political consensus on the estate tax, there’s little consensus globally: Japan, Germany and the United Kingdom all have estate or inheritance taxes, for instance, while Australia and Canada don’t. Sweden abolished its tax in 2004.
A wealthy individual who wants to avoid the estate tax can choose from a handful of legal maneuvers based on quirks in the tax code. One device, called the “Walton GRAT,” basically gives extremely rich people a new way to do what Rockefeller did after 1916: make tax-free transfers to heirs. Created inadvertently by Congress in 1990 as it shut down an earlier loophole, the GRAT won the blessing of the U.S. Tax Court in 2000 over the protests of the Internal Revenue Service. Another, called the “dynasty trust,” is being promoted by states such as South Dakota and Delaware that have tailored their trust laws to facilitate federal tax avoidance. And today’s super-low interest rates are turning charitable vehicles known as “Jackie O.” trusts, which were never intended to become tax shelters, into opportunities to reduce tax bills.
The estate tax sprang to life when the Great War raged in Europe and President Woodrow Wilson needed cash for an arsenal. Progressives were also concerned that the fortunes amassed during the 19th century’s Gilded Age might spawn a permanent American plutocracy; some supporters today cite the same fear. Many Americans, though, have considered the levy to be an unjust burden on families and a form of double taxation. Starting in the 1990s, Republicans in Congress pushed to end what they called the “death tax.” In 2001, they won a temporary phase-out of the tax culminating in a one-year repeal in 2010; New York Yankees owner George Steinbrenner was among the wealthy Americans to die during that period. When the time came for permanent legislation, the deal between Obama and Republicans succeeded in keeping the estate tax in place indefinitely, although in a weakened form. That didn't end the argument: Many Republicans besides Trump would still like to abolish the tax altogether, while Obama as well as Clinton has argued for increasing the rate. Obama has called for another tax on inherited wealth by changing income-tax rules on inherited property. So far, Congress has done nothing about the growing tally of loopholes that make the tax easy to avoid; in fact, some of them are wider than ever. As the mice thrive, the cats may have altogether lost interest in the game.
The Reference Shelf
- Bloomberg News’s “Artful Dodgers’’ series on tax avoidance.
- An Internal Revenue Service history of the estate tax.
- George Cooper’s influential 1977 essay branding the levy a “voluntary” tax.
- Obama’s 2015 proposal to impose capital-gains taxes on asset transfers at death.
First published Jan. 7, 2014
To contact the writer of this QuickTake:
Zachary Mider in New York at email@example.com
To contact the editor responsible for this QuickTake:
Jonathan Landman at firstname.lastname@example.org