Skip to content
Subscriber Only
Mark Buchanan

The Misunderstanding at the Core of Economics

Kenneth Arrow's brilliant insight has been used to the wrong ends.
Out of equilibrium.

Out of equilibrium.

Photographer: Louisa Gouliamaki/AFP/Getty Images

The economist Kenneth Arrow, who died last month at age 95, was a model academic -- brilliant, creative, precise, unfailingly modest. If only his fellow economists would stop misrepresenting his work.

In the 1950s, Arrow and others proved a theorem that, many economists believe, put a rigorous mathematical foundation beneath Adam Smith's idea of the invisible hand. The theorem shows -- in a highly abstract model -- that producers and consumers can match their desires perfectly, given a particular set of prices. In this rarified atmosphere of “general equilibrium,” economic activity might take place efficiently without any central coordination, simply as a result of people pursuing their self-interest. It’s an insight that economists have used to argue for de-unionization, globalization and financial deregulation, all in the name of removing various frictions or distortions that prevent markets from achieving the elusive equilibrium.