Skip to content
Noah Feldman

Court Backs Snowden, Strikes Secret Laws

Decision vindicates his contention that NSA's collection practices are unlawful.
Snowden strikes again.

Snowden strikes again.

Photographer: Mandel Ngan/Getty Images

In a major vindication for Edward Snowden -- and a blow for the national security policy pursued by Republicans and Democrats alike -- the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit ruled Thursday that the National Security Agency’s metadata collection program is unlawful.  This is the most serious blow to date for the legacy of the USA Patriot Act and the surveillance overreach that followed 9/11.

The central question depended on the meaning of the word "relevant": Was the government's collection relevant to an investigation when it collects all the metadata for any phone call made to or from anywhere in the U.S.?