Biggest Trade in History to Accompany AAA Crisis: William Pesek
Asia is sitting on $2.6 trillion of U.S. Treasuries, at a time when one of the official arbiters of creditworthiness has just delivered a vote of reduced confidence. S&P said as much last week when it cut the U.S.’s sovereign rating to AA+. That’s what happens when politicians in Washington act more like stewards of a developing economy than a world leader.
Reassurances by U.S. Treasury Secretary Geithner are small comfort as Asian nations consider how to move beyond export- driven development models that compel them to buy Treasuries with their accumulated dollars. It’s time for Asia to figure out how to get beyond this trade, which locks it into soaking up ever more U.S. debt to keep their own currencies artificially weak. Here are 10 things Asian leaders need to think about as they try to get to the end of 2011 with their economies intact.
No. 1: Weathering a AAA crisis. S&P’s move is another acknowledgment that the U.S. is on the path of long-term decline unless it can reverse course. Yet the dollar is, for better or worse, the linchpin of our global system. Expect an adjustment process that might see other countries tossed out of the AAA club. That will unnerve investors still smarting from the meltdown of 2008. It forces Asia to confront a remarkable balancing act -- figuring out how to reduce dollar holdings without undermining markets and driving down the value of their own investments.
No. 2: Double-dip recession. The recent debt-ceiling deal in Washington begins siphoning money out of the U.S. economy at a time when fiscal and monetary stimulus efforts are winding down. Europe, meanwhile, is wrestling with a debt crisis that seems to be spreading from the periphery to the core. Asia proved that it can grow without much help from U.S. and European consumers for two or three years. What about four or five? Asia may have to adjust to life with slower growth.
No. 3: The money glut. We live in a world of zero, in which the Federal Reserve, Bank of Japan and European Central Bank are all essentially offering free money. Expect even more liquidity from the Fed, especially if unemployment rises. Economies from Thailand to South Korea worried about hot-money flows and asset bubbles a year ago haven’t seen anything yet.
No. 4: Europe’s meltdown. The U.S. is a sideshow compared with the euro zone. A Greek default seems unavoidable, and so are worsening conditions in Ireland, Portugal and Spain. Yet what should really scare markets is the specter of an Italian crash. German citizens are being told these economies are too big to fail and that their savings are needed to fund bailouts. Italy might be too big to save. What if Germans grow tired of bailing out Europe’s weak links and demand a return to the deutsche mark?
No. 5: Deflation, not inflation. Weakening global demand buttresses the view that consumer prices from the U.S. to Singapore will fall. The counterpoint is that liquidity provided by Washington, Tokyo and Frankfurt will make inflation the real risk. Inflation hawks point to gold trading about $1,700 an ounce to support their views. I side with the deflation scenario. Slack demand is the bigger problem.
No. 6: IPO bust. Even before the U.S. downgrade, shares of Blackstone Group LP and KKR & Co. were sliding on concern that market turmoil would hinder the buyout firms’ ability to sell shares in the companies they control. Asia has been an obvious initial public offering bright spot in recent years. Expect fewer of them. That means less money for expansion, research, hiring, wage growth and wealth creation.
No. 7: Chinese overheating. At the core of Asia’s impressive post-Lehman-Brothers performance has been China’s 10 percent growth. China needs it to placate the masses and keep the Communist Party in business. That risks domestic inflation that might roar out of control. Trouble in China is among the last things Asia, or the rest of the world, needs.
No. 8: Out of the blue. The unthinkable has an uncanny knack of happening. The list of events that could devastate markets include a Japanese bond-market crash, the “Arab Spring” sweeps through Beijing, an over-the-top provocation from North Korean leader Kim Jong Il, terrorist attacks and firefights in the South China Sea.
No. 9: Cooperation deficit. Asia puts on a great show of working together with countless summits, communiqués and conference calls. In reality, nations are becoming more inward looking and insular, not only in Asia but globally. It calls into question the whole idea of globalization. If ever there were a time for policy collaboration, it’s now.
No. 10: Leadership void. The world economy has rarely been in greater need of credible, savvy and forward-looking policies. Look around the globe. You won’t find them in Brussels, Tokyo or Washington. Not Beijing either. If we are heading into Global Financial Crisis 2.0, today’s crop of leaders and policy makers sure make me wonder if they are up to the challenge.
(William Pesek is a Bloomberg View columnist. The opinions expressed are his own.)
Read more Bloomberg View columns.
To contact the writer of this column: Willie Pesek in Tokyo at firstname.lastname@example.org
To contact the editor responsible for this story: James Greiff at email@example.com