Fidelity Settles FTC Case After Touting ‘Oligopoly’
Fidelity National Financial Inc. (FNF), the title insurer that called the industry an “oligopoly,” agreed to sell assets in Oregon and Michigan to settle a regulatory review into anticompetitive practices.
The insurer’s 2008 purchase of bankrupt rival LandAmerica Financial Group Inc. reduced competition in five Oregon regions, including the Portland area, and in Detroit, the Federal Trade Commission said in a statement today. The settlement will require the Jacksonville, Florida-based insurer to sell assets including data used for underwriting in those regions.
“Fidelity’s acquisition of the LandAmerica assets was anticompetitive in several local markets for the provision of title insurance information services,” the regulator said in the statement.
Chief Executive Officer Alan Stinson said in September 2009 that the declining number of companies selling title insurance has created an oligopoly, allowing insurers to raise prices to more profitable levels. The company posted its fourth straight quarterly profit increase in the period ended March 31, recovering from three straight losses.
The insurer declined 58 cents, or 4.2 percent, to $13.27, at 4:15 p.m. in New York Stock Exchange intraday trading. The stock had declined 1.4 percent this year.
The title insurance industry is dominated by No. 1 Fidelity, First American Financial Corp., (FAF) Stewart Information Services Corp. (STC) and Old Republic International Corp. (ORI) The four have a combined 89 percent market share, according to first-quarter data compiled by the Washington-based American Land Title Association, an industry group.
‘Best Rate Environment’
“We are probably in the best rate environment and best regulatory environment that we’ve been in for a long time,” Stinson said Sept. 16 at a Barclays Plc conference. “We are seeing some rationality in pricing. I think you’d expect that as the industry consolidates,” he said “The industry has become more or less an oligopoly.”
Title insurers use their records and public documents to verify a seller is the home’s true owner and that the property is free from liens. They collect a one-time premium at the closing of the purchase and pay costs that may arise if someone disputes the new owner’s right to the property -- claiming, for instance, that the boundaries weren’t properly recorded.
Fidelity spokeswomen Marcia Danzeisen didn’t immediately return a call seeking comment.
To contact the reporter on this story: Inyoung Hwang in New York at email@example.com.
To contact the editor responsible for this story: Dan Kraut at firstname.lastname@example.org