Skip to content
CityLab
Justice

The Next New Deal Must Be for Black Americans, Too

If Joe Biden hopes to enact an ambitious recovery agenda modeled on the New Deal, he must confront its racist legacy.

Franklin D. Roosevelt instituted a slate of sweeping new initiatives and an alphabet soup of federal agencies during the New Deal. But while Black Americans should have been the greatest beneficiaries of these programs, in many cases they benefitted the least — or not at all. 

Franklin D. Roosevelt instituted a slate of sweeping new initiatives and an alphabet soup of federal agencies during the New Deal. But while Black Americans should have been the greatest beneficiaries of these programs, in many cases they benefitted the least — or not at all. 

Photographer: Bettmann/Bettmann

For many Black and brown Americans, 2021 brought renewed optimism about advancing a racial justice agenda. With a new presidential administration, the racist despot will soon be removed, and the first African, Asian, Caribbean American and female vice president sworn in. Congress will be fully under Democratic control, and with a new mandate for change after a year of anti-racist uprisings that were among the largest protests in American history. Even the horrifying attack on the Capitol offered some rays of hope that honest conversations about the white supremacist roots of the U.S. are possible. As the Covid-19 vaccine began its slow but steady rollout, cheery forecasts emerged for a “v-shaped recovery” that could pull the economy out of an economic crisis often compared to the Great Depression. 

In looking forward, Democratic leaders including President-elect Joe Biden, often harken back to the federal government’s response to that period — the New Deal. But for Black Americans, the New Deal left an ambivalent legacy that does not offer an easy template for change. Many argue it deepened racial inequalities — widening gaps in employment, education and wealth between white and Black Americans. Those looking to hold the Biden-Harris administration accountable for its commitment to advancing racial justice need to understand how and why the New Deal left so many behind, so its history is not repeated.